Originally Posted by EyeballEyeball:
“I thought Boy Meets Girl and Cradle To Grave were great. I preferred Boy Meets Girl but found both funny. Nice to see both get a decent rating.”
Boy Meets Girl has real potential. It has a sort of feel of the old ITV show Watching but not yet as funny.
The leads blended well and the scenes involving the revelation by Judy were pretty much as it does happen but the exaggerated extended family dragged it down somewhat. They are presumably there to emphasise the reactions against both the transgender and age gap issues of the central relationship. But risk bringing the show down if they are over done.
If it gets time to develop beyond its unusual premise into a comedy about the two main characters it can really work,. If it goes off on too much of a crusade by bringing in every possible prejudice against Judy then it might easily become a one trick pony.
Worthy as it is, and in breaking the new ground that it has it is worthy, it has to remember that it is a sit com so being funny matters more than anything else.
As an example, see Sense 8 - the brilliant Netflix series by the Wachowski's and J Michael Straczynski - where one of the best characters in it is Nomi, a trans character played by a trans actress, but that - whilst not being ignored - does not dominate the show and the character becomes real as Nomi not a trans woman.
I trust the BBC will not go quite so far as Netflix in giving us nude sex scenes with Freema Ageyaman. But they have to ensure Boy Meets Girl develops the character and not just the issues.
Good start, though, probably gaining somewhat from the lead and the lack of competition elsewhere. But what happens next week will be key as Boy Meets Girl will have been marmite to those who tuned in so will lose viewers.