Originally Posted by stv viewer:
“I think network shows be it Scotland/ England only or across the network really need good presenters to be successful. Someone with a bit of personality.
I liked Paddy but he just didnt work with a everyone. While Ewen and Cat have a wider appeal and I suppose people can relate to them more.
The Friday/Saturday network shows are now the only shows across the network bar overnights. I get why they have these network shows as there are less radio listeners on a Friday/ Saturday night and it saves money but they just dont appeal to me.”
I don't think Paddy's show worked in Scotland because there just wasn't enough discipline in the production of it. Whereas if you listen to the equivalent Heart show at that time of the morning with Stephen Mulhern and Emma Willis, they were given enough room to show a bit of personality but not so much they rambled on forever, or went on about stuff local to them which didn't matter to anyone else (a Paddy link about a seaside resort in the north of England being a particular lowlight - that doesn't matter if he does it on ITV, it does if someone's listening to Clyde 1). The trick with the Heart show seemed to be giving personality to those who wanted it without intruding into the music for those who weren't bothered, or just wanted someone to chat but get off quickly. It's quite a skill actually.
I also feel - with apologies to viewers in the north of England - that there's less appeal to shows being networked from Manchester than there is from London. See also Galaxy and Real Radio vs Heart and Capital. There's at least some perceived glamour to having big name presenters in London versus jocks who just happened to be in Manchester when the decision was taken to network the show.
I wonder if there's a little bit of succession planning going on with the decision to acquire Ewen and Cat and the decision to move Greigsy to Clyde. There really doesn't seem to be any rush to move George Bowie out of the breakfast seat, he is still Mr Glasgow and the west and hugely successful, but it doesn't hurt to have a strong line-up on your flagship station.