Originally Posted by stv viewer:
“I get what you mean but Gina only does one show a week on Clyde one and occasionally does cover but not often. I think occasional cover is ok but Paul on breakfast doesnt make sense”
Since when was age an issue?
As an example - Alan Edwards is in his earlyish 30's yet manages to present the BC2 format very well, likewise, at the opposite end of the spectrum, George Bowie is just 2 years shy of 50 yet both presents Breakfast on one of the biggest BC1 stations and presents the new Scotland-wide Friday night dance music show (and regularly has sell-out events at night clubs across Scotland as well, so must be doing something right).
To give another example - Jim Gellatly is another presenter who is almost 50, yet, he is regularly featured on stations and is a well known champion of new performers and has an almost encyclopaedic knowledge of music.
If we were to apply the logic that the age of the presenter had a bearing on where they could host a show, then we'd be ruling out the some of the best quality presenters the country has to offer, both young and old (think - the likes of Fat Brestovca and Ryan Borthwick on BC1 are only 20… puts them more in the Clyde 3 bracket, no?), and it'd no doubt ultimately do nothing to improve the stations. In fact, it'd probably be nothing more than an
ageist practice and would bring more unfair dismissal claims such as the one put forward by Adrian Coll and Kevin Cameron
a few years ago.
The content ultimately matters more than the age of the presenter IMO.
Oh, and regarding Gina - IMO, it's a pleasure to hear her back on Clyde 1, her chat is good on what would otherwise be a generic afternoon show, before the dreary "Vodafone Big Top 40" which is about as content light as an advert break.
EDIT: Probably also worth pointing out, remember the vast majority of the presenters have no direct control over the music in the playlist (GB on his GBX shows and Tony Blackburn being two notable examples across BC1 and BC2), but, even if it is out of their assumed eras it doesn't mean they can't present a credible show around it - just like you wouldn't expect a doctor who qualified in the 1980s to still be practicing 1980s era medicine, you wouldn't expect a DJ who started in the 1980s to only specialise in 1980s era music - continuing professional development is a thing in nearly every industry.