Originally Posted by jlp95bwfc:
“The fire in the end was an accident. They cannot prove otherwise.”
Exactly.
Far be it for me to defend Tracy but she did not light the candle intending to commit arson or kill anybody, she wasn't to know that it would cause something else to catch light and arguably, if Carla hadn't been so drunk she'd have woken when Tracy came in, lit the candle and it caught the curtain so was also negligent, especially when taking care of an 11 year old child.
Basically, if they couldn't charge Carla with Arson or Murder, they wouldn't be able to charge Tracy
Trespass and theft of Carla's keys (she didn't actually break and enter) but if Tracy maintains her innocence and Robery doesn't give a statement (Carla doesn't know he knows) then it is one woman's word against another with no physical evidence so the CPS probably wouldn't proceed.