There is a real problem in this country and I just don't understand why
Originally Posted by farlofan:
“Just out of interest - if a motorist kills someone while being under the influence, should they be let off the hook because it's a disease they can't help, in the same way that a driver with heart disease having a heart attack would?”
No because it's an existing condition. You have to let the DVLA know if you have any medical impediment to drive, your licence is cancelled, and constantly being over the limit certainly qualifies! It's just the same as if you were to go blind. That said I'm sure many alcoholics keep quiet about it, hopefully only drive when they're safe to, and am sure many others hope to one day improve, so even if they don't drive through bad patches they wouldn't want their licence taken as it's a struggle to get back, if possible at all (I wouldn't know but perhaps they see you as a constant risk).
Interestingly, I believe in Japan being drunk was a defence against certain crimes (not sure about now, and drink driving wouldn't count I should think)

But then, they have a very different drinking culture there. There are alcohol vending machines selling bottles of spirits even. Not once in half a decade there did I see a student using them (or smoking) and very, very few obvious alcoholics like you do in the UK. Then again most businessmen would go out at least a few nights a week drinking, and smoking was the norm.
Originally Posted by GrozzyGirl:
“Do you think alcoholics drink because others do?
The partners of sober alcoholics do not abstain from drinking.
Try looking at the traditions and 12 steps of Alcoholics Anonymous and Al Anon
If she going to drink she will, if she decides to stay sober, she will and he can't make her drink or stop her from drinking.”
It must be different by area then. Around London I know it's common that they're told not to go anywhere with alcohol, avoid friends who drink (I've lost a few because they only hang out with other totally sober folk now), some of them even split from their partners if they won't go sober with them.
However not all problem drinkers go to AA.