Originally Posted by Libretio:
“There was no dictating, simply a statement of fact. Your comment came across as especially offensive, moreso because it was based on nothing more than personal opinion. You ascribed ugly motives to Austin's behaviour that could not be proven, and you described it as 'sickening'. That was indefensible. And you're trying to do the same with my response, accusing me of 'dictating what's right and wrong', when all I'm actually doing is trying to make sense of your incredibly offensive post. You cannot be surprised by this. The only reason I threatened to contact the mods (besides being offended by your accusation) was because I wanted to gauge your response before deciding how to proceed. As it happens, you may not be very happy with me right now, but at least you haven't been a bitch about it.
And that is your prerogative. However, that isn't the case for everyone else, and they're free to make their own choices. Austin could have gone into the Diary Room, raised a private toast, and asked the producers not to show it, but he can't dictate what gets broadcast. He opted to do it publicly, because he felt it was the right thing to do. It was his grief, his brother. Not yours or mine, or anyone else's. His.”
“There was no dictating, simply a statement of fact. Your comment came across as especially offensive, moreso because it was based on nothing more than personal opinion. You ascribed ugly motives to Austin's behaviour that could not be proven, and you described it as 'sickening'. That was indefensible. And you're trying to do the same with my response, accusing me of 'dictating what's right and wrong', when all I'm actually doing is trying to make sense of your incredibly offensive post. You cannot be surprised by this. The only reason I threatened to contact the mods (besides being offended by your accusation) was because I wanted to gauge your response before deciding how to proceed. As it happens, you may not be very happy with me right now, but at least you haven't been a bitch about it.
And that is your prerogative. However, that isn't the case for everyone else, and they're free to make their own choices. Austin could have gone into the Diary Room, raised a private toast, and asked the producers not to show it, but he can't dictate what gets broadcast. He opted to do it publicly, because he felt it was the right thing to do. It was his grief, his brother. Not yours or mine, or anyone else's. His.”
Exactly, it's his choice, just as it was Chloe's choice whether or not she wanted to participate. So why is he screaming at her face about it? Because it's all about the attention.
Also, relax, questioning someone's motives on a reality TV show is not disgusting etc etc. would you say that about the hordes of people who roll their eyes whenever an x factor singer tearfully dedicates a song to their dearly departed and says they're doing it because it was said dearly departed's dream to see them succeed as a singer?




LOL.