Why is James getting all this flack for his choice, why aren't people asking questions about why Natashia picked Sherrie? If she had picked Bobby it would have been alot different, it seems James is being hauled over the coals for doing exactly the same thing as all the others, nothing is being said about them. The only reason his choice is such a problem for everyone is because Jenna has caused a fuss over it. The woman who called him rotten with Farrah and put him up for eviction, why then, does she expect him to save her?

As far as I can see, James made his choice, all this in depth thinking about why he did what he did I find incredible, he had 1-2 minutes to decide on live tv, do you really think he was able to compute all the stuff he is being accused of? I know for a fact I wouldn't be able to think of anything in those circumstances but the people he was facing, he had Emma asking for his answer, he did what he thought was best.

As for the whole grandfather story being used as an excuse, why? He has talked a great deal about this in the house to several of the HM's, it's not the first time he has mentioned it. It looks to me as people are just looking for reasons to slate him, as he has done very little wrong in there, so any chance to try and blacken his character has been jumped on. What ever people think about his reasons, he still remains the best housemate in there by a long way and I hope he wins.

I guess folk aren't asking questions over why Natasha picked Sherrie is because it was an obvious choice......she is closer to Sherrie.
Don't get me wrong, I like James, but his choice of saving Janice was odd, considering he knew full well she would be saved by Chlovie. His reason for picking Janice, so she could be there for Chloe, were the opposite of his feelings earlier, when he stated Chloe needed to stand up for herself and not be dependant on others.

Oh who cares? We got rid of the odious Farrah and Jenna is p****d off! Result!!

well it seems that Jenna has been sleeping in James and Austin's bed for a few day now, but the HLs are only suggesting this happened after Farrah's eviction....Janice was saying in the DR that's why she thinks Jenna has gotton upset

personally they need to get over James choice as he owes them s**t

He's definitely playing a game. The reason they were all flabbergasted is because he is not close to Janice at all. Saying "I did it for Chloe" is laughable as well, especially as he knew she would save Janice herself.

Very telling that when Austin and Jenna called him out on his BS, all he could reply was "I'm not discussing this any more".

After discussing it endlessly for 20 minutes or more and going round in circles. It certainly wasn't 'all he could reply' at all - it's not his fault Austin and Jenna are to busy listening to the sound of their own voices to hear what he has to say.