He voted to save Janice for Chloe because of his grandad blah, blah.

Why did neither Rylan or Emma say...

"Well surely Chloe would have saved her!"

It's so ridiculous.

His face closing his eyes when the seconds were counting until the winner was announced.

If the man was ugly he wouldn't be anywhere near as popular.

He could have saved Bobby and left Austin with the same choice.

If its true then it's not a) going to change and b) not an excuse.

Exactly. Therefore making his saving of Janice MORE genuine; he had a good reason to save her and had NO intention of saving Farrah [which would have happened if he chosen Jenna].

He could have saved Bobby, but had a REASON to save Janice.

Not necessarily. If he had chose jenna and then it would have left austin to choose between Farrah and Bobby or Farrah and Janice.

Still being discussed?

He has never changed his story (like a lot of hms do).

My question was, A: why didn't any of the presenters say, " well surely Chloe and Stevi would have chosen Janice, "

And B: It is an excuse

Why would he change his reason now?