I was stunned when she went out. Even more stunned when a couple of sets later they called back Holly or Polly or whatever her name was to say 'We've made a mistake you're back in'
The criticism of her by SC was that Stand by Me would have been more interesting as a reggae version, when I find it hard to think of a bigger cliche that stand by me as a reggae version, and thought ther interpretation was far more interesting. Even it it would - he's a producer, if she is able to sing a song it shouldn't be beyond his wit to manage a reggae version if that's what he wants.
I thought her vocals were really smooth and easy, and her personality as a performer was quirky and interesting. I am sad to see her go.