I was actually quite impressed by her. On the first day she was completely out of her depth and I agreed with Claude's criticism, but I think when they actually started work she recovered pretty well. She seemed to handle things quite professionally, there didn't really seem to be any disputes, she made sure the team were out selling at lunchtime (the most crucial part of the whole task) and she didn't go to pieces when things went wrong (like when it turned out that the squid wasn't very good quality, she was just like, 'Well, it's what we have, let's just do the best we can'.)

Also I liked that she was ethically-minded - she refused to set the price too high on a really poor-quality product. I like people who have some morals - the process is really cut-throat so I'm not sure if that will come back to bite her, but in the real world having principles like that is an asset. It means that people actually want to work with and for you, which is always good.

She was by no means perfect, but I think she could have been much worse. She deserved the win, in my eyes.

I thought she was good too, definitely one of the best "reluctant project managers" there has ever been on the show. She got some really good points across, she made sure that they were out selling at lunchtime and picked good products.

Did find it a bit difficult telling the difference between her and Charleine a couple of times though But both of them did well tonight and I hope they both go far.

Liked her, was the only member of the team with any integrity in my view. Very glad to see her win

I thought Charlene was really the stand-out performer on that team. She seemed to do everything right. Could be one to watch there.

On the other hand, she could be the next Ella Jade - looks very strong for the first few tasks, and then becomes PM and gets the nightmare edit.

I liked her and I'm glad she made the ethics case even if the show format does not care about creating sustainable business models and just want you to flog cheap stuff I liked that she wasn't going down to that level.

Charlene got a good edit early on but didn't do a whole lot which makes me think she's one to watch to do well in the competition, getting early edits like that when not a PM or in danger is a good sign on these shows.

Was Charlene the woman with the strangely coloured jacket? She's definitely my early favourite
edit: just looked it up, no she's not, my early favourite is Ruth!

I don't feel particularly strong about Selina either way

I think you're thinking of Ruth (the older one)?

Charlene wore a pale blue jacket, if I remember correctly. I think she might be Welsh - she sounded slightly Welsh to me, though I haven't checked where they're all from.

Think that she was outshined by Richard and Charleine on her team (though they didn't really have to save her from anything, as the other team was horrendous).

I thought Selina was very impressive.

Normally these idiots are all mouth and are reduced to being schoolkids when they're faced with a task.

But she got stuck in. Was very professional in her speaking and manner.

I have her in the office sweepstake and so I think she's brilliant!

Seriously, I thought she was good in first task, a bit annoying in second.

Yes, same. On the first task, I thought she could be one to watch, but yesterday I just thought she seemed a bit silly.

Then again, it's early days. I remember in the first couple of weeks of Series 8, I thought Jenna was dreadful and couldn't go fast enough. But by the time she was fired in Week 9, I was really sad to see her go. It took a while, but she grew on me.