what do you think of the marking today?

Quite a few on the same level.
I think that Katie deserved her position on the top of the leaderboard.

under-marked - kelly
over-marked - jamelia

Under marked: Jay

I don't really think anyone was overmarked. They were all about right, but with two mistakes Jay shouldn't have been that low.

Wombling free...

Anita was undermarked but you always get that going first i hope Peter goes first next week

I know Jay had a bad night ...but 5 from Craig.

He still managed to dance better then many of them.

Overmarked (massively) - Jamelia

I don't think so. For someone to have made so much improvement, she was marked accordingly.

I hope so as well

I think she was massively undermarked IMO.

Georgia and Giovanni undermarked

Anita and Gleb undermarked.

Jeremy and Karen overmarked (especially in relation to above two)

So much better than Peter Andre and Jay is a lot easier on the eye too.

Thought the leaderboard was pretty much right in that the right people were in the top section and the right people were in the bottom section.

I might have given Anita a mark or two more than she got and Daniel a few less, but mostly the general order was right for me.

I agree.

The judges of Elstree Common are we

I'm not sure why you think she was overmarked she produced a great Charleston and it was one of the best dances of the night...

Anita was definitely undermarked

Katie was clearly overmarked.
Jamelia was marked fairly, but people seem not to be able to be nice about her.
I think Jeremy was over marked by all but Craig.


Yes Jay was under marked, it felt like they rated him by comparison to last week when they should have marked him in relation to his competition. He was a good 7.

Agreed, apart from Jamelia (even though it was her best dance so far).

Undermarked:

Georgia & Giovanni
Anita & Gleb

Overmarked

Katie & Anton
Peter & Janette
Jeremy & Karen

that is how I saw it as well

I'll let Katie off as I really enjoyed her dance..otherwise I completely agree. When it comes to Georgia and Anita, I always feel they don't get the marks they deserve, especially in relation to others.

I'm just a sofa fan but undermarked Jay,Georgia,Anita and overmarked Jamelia and Peter

Yep, especially as Katie had a couple of slips at the start of the dance!

Carol actually did a proper dance for the first time ever, albeit with very mediocre technique. She deserved to score considerably higher than Jeremy's abomination of a jive and Kirsty's disaster of a Paso. They were both overmarked.

Jeremy's dance was kind of funny, but it was probably some of the most bizarre and gangly goings-on in the history of Strictly. His legs scare me a bit.

Undermarked: Jay, Daniel, Anita

Overmarked: Jeremy and Kirsty

Undermarked: Anita and Georgia

Overmarked: Jamelia and Peter