Overmarked : Kirsty, Jeremy, Jamelia
Don't think anybody was particularly undermarked. Katie, Kellie and Anita all could have been bumped up a bit but I have no objection to their scores really. I don't think Carol was undermarked in general, but should have been more than one point higher than that garbage Kirsty put out.

Over-marked : Peter
Under-marked: Georgia, Kirsty
Over-marked: Peter
Over-marked: Jeromy
Over-marked: Peter
Under-marked: Katie (Deserved at least another 9)
Over-marked: Peter

so true

overmarked
Peter& Jeanette
Jeremy& Karen
Kirsty& Brendan
Iwan& Ola (Cha-Cha-Cha should have been 1 from Craig)
undermarked
Katie& Anton
G&G rumba week 3

After rewatching dances this is what I think

Undermarked

Jay: Jive (W3) Quickstep (W4), Paso (W5), Argentine Tango (W7), Foxtrot (W8), Salsa (W9), Quickstep-A-thon (W10), Viennese Waltz (W12), Showdance (W13), Paso (W13)

Anita: Charleston (W2), American Smooth (W3), Samba (W4), Tango (W5), Waltz (W6), Quickstep (W8), Rumba (W10), Argentine Tango (W11)

Katie: Viennese Waltz (W4), Rumba (W8), American Smooth (W9)

Kellie: Charleston (W3), Jive (W5), Viennese Waltz (W11)

Helen: Salsa (W4), Samba (W6), Viennese Waltz (W10)

Georgia: Rumba (W3), Quickstep (W4)

Jamelia: Charleston (W4)

Ainsley: Salsa (W2)


Overmarked

Georgia: Samba (W7), American Smooth (W9), Paso (W10), Foxtrot (W11), Cha Cha Cha (W12)

Kellie: Samba (W8), Salsa (W10), Tango (W13)

Peter: Viennese Waltz (W8), Jive (W9)

Jeremy: Charleston (W3)

Agree!!

Agree with all apart from Jay being undermarked, Katie being undermarked, Kellie being undermarked, Ainsley being undermarked and Georgia being overmarked.

Redid some after realising some were wrong

B]Undermarked[/b]

Jay: Jive (W3) Quickstep (W4), Paso (W5), Argentine Tango (W7), Foxtrot (W8), Salsa (W9), Quickstep-A-thon (W10), Viennese Waltz (W12), Showdance (W13), Paso (W13)

Anita: Charleston (W2), American Smooth (W3), Samba (W4), Tango (W5), Waltz (W6), Quickstep (W8), Rumba (W10), Argentine Tango (W11)

Katie: Viennese Waltz (W4), Rumba (W8), American Smooth (W9)

Helen: Salsa (W4), Samba (W6), Viennese Waltz (W10)

Georgia: Rumba (W3), Quickstep (W4)

Jamelia: Charleston (W4)

Ainsley: Salsa (W2)


Overmarked

Georgia: Samba (W7), American Smooth (W9), Paso (W10), Foxtrot (W11), Cha Cha Cha (W12) Showdance (W13)

Kellie: Samba (W8), Salsa (W10), Viennese Waltz (W11), Tango (W13)

Peter: Viennese Waltz (W8), Jive (W9)

Jeremy: Charleston (W3)

Haha I think you could say our opinions differ on this quite radically!!

Do agree with you on Jay's jive, should have had four tens, week 3 or not, but all the ones you have down of Georgia's, barring possibly the cha cha cha I think were undermarked personally, particularly the paso (33???) & the showdance which I found incredibly moving!! Personal taste though so fair enough!!
Oh I agreed on Kellie's final tango too, never worth 4 tens!!

It's good we have different takes on who we think were undermarked and overmarked Regarding Georgia my opinion of her dances were the following en though

Samba was good and fast but there were mistakes in it and if that dance was done by some of the other couples they would have been penalised.

American Smooth - Good dance but it was overrated I personally thought Katie 's was better which was done the same week

Paso - Not her fault but didn't like the song and didn't like the end. Not a patch on Jay's or Anita's.

Foxtrot - Felt a bit bland and didn't like the theme.

Showdance - I didn't like it and especially the blindfold bit which has previously been done on Dancing With The Stars.

Sorry I don't mean to be horrible I do think two of her dances were undermarked her Rumba in week 3 and Quickstep in week 4 were my favourites dances from her.

I would add
Undermarked
Jay's Waltz (Wk 2) -undermarked by Craig

Overmarked
Kellie's Rumba (Wk 12)

Jay under marked throughout the series. Kellie overmarked from week 10 onwards.

Jays Salsa was really undermarked,that was such a difficult lift.