Originally Posted by intoxication:
“Yeah I get your post but if they said she never achieved housemate status then she was never a housemate to me and I don't consider her as one”
Fair enough, lets just agrree to disagree, i think it just comes down to whether one puts more weight on what BB SAID or what Beinazier actually DID
Just because BB say she wasnt officially a hm (because of the opening twist which was designed for hms to earn immunity from the first vote and NOTHING else whatsoever - doesn't mean she wasn't.. Once they'd completed the tasks and were immune they had no other advantages and were not treated differently - ergo the opening twist was a series of immunity tasks in all but name - same as the hms were hms in all but name from launch !
To spell it out .. If Beinazier wasn't a hm consider the following.....
1) She entered the house on launch night with the other hms with exactly the same chance of staying beyond the first week as them.
2) The length of her stay was NOT pre-ordained
3) She was not treated differently to any other hm or disadvantaged in anyway during her stay.
4) She took part in all tasks
5) She took part in a public vote
6) She was evicted because she lost the publc vote
In what way does any of that make her not a hm or (her experience) different to any other hm ever?!