I think Carol should win SCD this year because ..................

(OK I will start and you all can join below in reply's)

She has a great sense of fun on the dance floor, she has a nice sunny personality and can tell you if its going to rain or not each day is from a great nation.

Because you will single-handedly re-launch the campaign for Scottish independence if she doesn't.

There'll be fireworks ...

But it is a dancing competition and her dance ability is a lot more limited.

You need to make a decision Tom.
Kirsty or Carol?
Scotland needs guidance - splitting the vote is fraught with danger

She's more popular than Kirsty

Especially with sparklers and treacle toffee to buy.

There's Trick or Treating to get over first

It has already been established that Strictly come Dancing is a Saturday night light entertainment show, not a dancing competition, I personally like Carol.

this could easily degenerate into a breast v. leg man thread...

Because if she doesn't it will be raining all the time. And not men.