I really really like his voice. I know image wise, some folks would say he needs work, but there is something genuine I like about him. I think Jennifer or Kerri Anne should be through instead of Bupsi (i think Ebru is way over rated). But I am interested to see what happens with Max hopefully Simon does well by him.

Bland and will be out within the first few weeks.

I think Simon has lost his mind

He did really well in six chair and judges houses though. Jennifer I thought was fab but she isn't very current maybe? ALthough I dont deny she has an increcible voice, Kerrie - Anne I thought was very good, Ebru I thought she was quite bland to be honest

Should have been Jennifer.

I personally thought Max was the best tonight and deserved to go through

don't talk about your staged bland dull winner like that

He won't win.

I think he's good and I'm glad he got through.

I agree. Good voice !!!!

Simon doesn't wanna win, he hates his category... I do like Max though...I'm just angry Jennifer didn't get through...regarding Simon's choices, I think he should be very careful if he doesn't win...Max could get the generic guy with guitar vote which is powerful...Anton could get the Christopher Maloney vote even if he is ruined...and Bupsi could get the joke vote, so who knows...

Me too, I think he was easily the best over tonight. Great voice and more interesting to watch than the rest of them

I agree. I would have replaced Bupsi with Jennifer but think Simon got the other 2 right

He fills the white guy with guitar slot

Agree and it was clear Simon Cowell was not going to pick him until the crowd changed his mind.

Jennifer was the only one I was sure about making the top 3. That was very shocking.

Be out in week 2 after Bupsi

Absolutely ridiculous that Jennifer didn't get through.

Bupsi will be in for ages sadly, hopefully Max will be too and he deserves it more as he is talented.


Jennifer had an amazing voice she (or Kerrie Anne) should be through instead of Bupsi

I think he has a good voice but I find him quite forgettable and a little generic if I'm honest

I thought he did a hell of a lot more than that.

I don't care much for him - Simon's obviously trying to cover all bases, and thinks this lad might be popular.

said in the main thread i didn't think cowell would put both anton and jennifer through as i think they are a bit samey but was shocked max got the last spot still

He has potential

I don't think he lacks any more charisma than some of the other contestants but I'm not a fan. The guitar/acoustic thing doesn't float my boat. I think he could win though.