Results:Did Cheryl make the right choices?
Yes - She chose the perfect 3!
55 (41.67%)
No - BEKLN Mile should've got through
47 (35.61%)
No - New Kings Order should've got through
25 (18.94%)
No - Melody Stone should've got through
13 (9.85%)
Voters: 132. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Did Cheryl make the right choices? (POLL)
Imo I would've put Melody Stone through over Reggie N Bollie, but I agree with her other 2 choices.
probably
all 6 were pretty dreadful but she put through the three that will be the most talked about come the live shows
Don't know why she loves Alien so much
My three would have been 4th impact,Melody Stone and Bekln mile. Ailen and the group with be gone finish few weeks with four impact finding 3rd in the show
Originally Posted by Corinne_Brooks:
“Don't know why she loves Alien so much”
they are style over substance
rely on snazzy outfits, big dance routines and miming
vocally quite poor
they will remind her of herself
I'd have a bet on Alien Uncovered being the first contestants to go in the live shows. They remind me of so many girl bands that have gone the same way, never to be heard of again. BEKLN Mile would have been a much safer choice.
Alien are horrendous...so I would have put any three other than them.
Cheryl got it wrong she should've put through the gospel group, alien and bekln
Why 4th impact they're utterly dire
Yup I'm just glad melody tone didn't get through so I'm happy 😊
I don't like any of the groups, but I'm astonished that she put those two guys through.
i am quietly delighted that reggie n bollie got through I didn't think they had a chance but I love them and they're fun, i think they'll liven up the live shows
Originally Posted by fluffysheep123:
“i am quietly delighted that reggie n bollie got through I didn't think they had a chance but I love them and they're fun, i think they'll liven up the live shows”
Maybe one live show.
I think she should have picked Bekln Mile and New Kings Order
I think she got it right.
I like Alien and Menn On Poinnt (whatever they're called now). Can't stand 4th Impact but they were a shoo in.
The 2 gospel acts and the other boyband are all talented but all 3 acts were so dated that they really offered nothing that's not been seen a million times before.
BEKLN over the 2 African guys who sound like an inferior version of already successful current act Fuse ODG.
When the first two groups announced were all female,i knew there wouldn't be a 3rd so immediately Melody Tone were out,but was surprised by the 3rd Choice
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Why 4th impact they're utterly dire”
4th Impact have generated too much press/whatever to be left out
I think they're alright, but they're all about shouty attitude instead of light and shade / dynamics; give them a quiet song to sing and they fall apart
I think BEKLN or NKO should've gone through instead of Reggie & Bollie.
I think Cheryl, Rita and Nick have a difficult choices this year. Simon not so much as I think the overs category is the weakest.
I think she was right to chose 4th Impact Alien Uncovered but I wouldn't have chosen Reggie & Bollie, infact I would have swapped them out at 6 chair challenge. I can see them being made the joke act/Jedward type act even though I don't think that's what Cheryl wants for them. Instead of them I would have chosen either BKLN Mile or New Kings Order, and out of them 2 I think BKLN Mile would have won out over New Kings Order
Would've gone with 4th Impact , Becklyn , New Kings Order
I don't know how she didn't choose either of them she always messes up big time at judges houses.