I think he got 2/3 right. Josh should've got through instead of Che.

I thought he chose the perfect three. Having said that, he had the best category - all six were stunning, so he couldn't really go wrong.

I agree with OP I would have had Josh over Che

Josh over Seann.

I couldn't disagree more. Josh is bland and boring imo.

Seann was a dead cert and deservedly so.

Mason Noise proved in judges houses he is actually a really talented singer, and he knows how to perform. I think he earned his spot in the top 3.

However I would've swapped out Che for Ben. Ben's judges houses performance was stunning, my favourite of the 6. Plus with his rock/alternative leanings it would've been an amazing, diverse top 3. So him being eliminated was definitely a shame. (He was so fit too. )

Nick made the best choices out of all of the judges imo
All his are so good even Mason he a different voice and will be interesting in the liveshows

Ben over Che! Josh or Simon over Che would have been greay too! Che is good vocally but so dated and so devoid of personality.

Another thing that frustrates me about this is that the show knows Che/Anton will top the votes every week - they're going to be on Maloney levels of annoying in bringing down! They could easily have changed that to make it more interesting but they didn't! They want another bland male winner clearly dont they?

I wouldn't have brought Mason back because it may make good headlines but there's nothing about his voice that's original. He's like a bad Justin Timberlake tribute act. I'm not sure who i'd put in his place but they're all more likable and winning the xfactor is more about people liking you than talent, as is obvious from how few winners have actually lasted.

I knew Mason was going through, but literally any of the three of the other guys would've been better in my opinion. If I had to say just one I'd pick Simon but... oh well.

Any of the other 3 boys would have been a much better choice than Mason.

You can't be saying Anton is bland!

Josh and Simon both should have been in the three..
Very disappointing selection.

100% agree.

Any of the other 3 but not Mason.

Josh instead of petulant Mason. In fact anyone except for him.

This makes me think, it's such a Shame that singers like Monica, Ebru and josh have already gone, they were all exceptional and I'd have thought just the kind of credible artists that will help the X factor brand. Shame we couldn't have a top 16. The show this year seems beset with bad decisions, the presenters! !?

Josh instead of Che, but otherwise Nick had it perfect