Yes she is good but she isn't anything different to other people out there

i loved her in auditions but not loved either of the songs shes sung so far, boring.

I don't get. what is so great and the love for Che, or Reggie and Billie, but there you go, different things for different folk, it's easy really.

She is good and young... what not to like??

She has an incredible voice, looks great, is young (so therefore has plenty of potential) and seems like a nice girl. She also showed last night that she can PERFORM, not just sing. She is the whole package. She has THE X FACTOR!!!

I agree 100%, she has it all!

She doesn't need to be different to anything else out there, that can come into it when it's finished. For now, she just needs to be good on the show. And she has been.

Can't see any way she is not going to win, obvious future star.

She really ticks every box

My only complaint is that sometimes she needs to hold back a little. E.g. Billie Jean is a not a belt-out ballad, and her vocals need to reflect that. Felt like she tacked on the vocal acrobatics at the end and it wasn't needed.

She reminds me of Britney/Mandy Moore in their heyday so watching her brings up a lot of nostalgia for me.

She has as incredible voice but the end of her Billie Jean performance was the end of any chance of me voting for her. The a capella "look how good my voice is" ending was inconsistent with the rest of it and made a mockery of what she'd done before.

I agree - sometimes less is more

She is going to be a huge star.

I think she'll be a big success too, but I think she's boring at the moment (which isn't surprising because she's only 17)

Also, like Lauren, I think she struggles with diction and other things (like breath control) below a certain volume at the moment; the part where's she sitting astride the chair sounds meh to me

I don't like the shrillness in her voice.