The judges make their favorites obvious. Both Craig and Darcy have admitted to ignoring the mistakes Georgia has made, this week and last week. Furthermore, she made at least two mistakes last week and still got 39. If Jay or Jamelia made mistakes they would get slaughtered.
Biased Judges
1 of 2
It is they definitely favour Georgia but I think the undermarking of Jay is tactical because they know he is doing well in the public vote and also its annoying me how Georgia always on last or near the end.
Jay was undermarked but liked Georgia - although Anita's dance was dramatic was paso light in steps for me
Funny how Helen can get 9s even after making mistakes while Jay has been docked points for his mistakes.
I find them biased towards KK as well. Although the QS was really good. Kellie's show off and me me behaviour is so grating!
Georgia was fab but she made a mistake so should not have got a ten. Even I noticed the mistake it was bloody obvious
Jay is always under marked. Imthinkmhei expect more from him somehow which is unfair. His salsa was brilliant.
Glad Peter finally got the mark he deserved.
Jay is always under marked. Imthinkmhei expect more from him somehow which is unfair. His salsa was brilliant.
Glad Peter finally got the mark he deserved.
Originally Posted by JH84:
“I find them biased towards KK as well. Although the QS was really good. Kellie's show off and me me behaviour is so grating!”
“I find them biased towards KK as well. Although the QS was really good. Kellie's show off and me me behaviour is so grating!”
He is mates with Kellie apparently. Craig always plays favourites.
Originally Posted by Logopolis:
“The judges make their favorites obvious. Both Craig and Darcy have admitted to ignoring the mistakes Georgia has made, this week and last week. Furthermore, she made at least two mistakes last week and still got 39. If Jay or Jamelia made mistakes they would get slaughtered.”
“The judges make their favorites obvious. Both Craig and Darcy have admitted to ignoring the mistakes Georgia has made, this week and last week. Furthermore, she made at least two mistakes last week and still got 39. If Jay or Jamelia made mistakes they would get slaughtered.”
yep agreed..jay should have said his braces or belt got caught or something
Kellie and Kevin's QS was dull and repetitive. I really thought they were looking at 8s across the board. Grossly over marked again! Her dress was probably the worst this series. -it didn't look as if it had been fitted for her.
Helen made loads of mistakes, especially after that spin where she was upside down and almost doing the splits. Whether she was dizzy or not I don't know but her dancing went to pieces after that. She got her steps wrong and stopped altogether on at least 3 occasions, yet the judges thought it was great. Obviously one of their favourites.
Georgia made mistakes two weeks in a row and it is ignored, I think she must be low with the public votes so they are keeping her high on the board.
Jay deserved a 10 from one of the judges, he and Anita owned the night.
Jay deserved a 10 from one of the judges, he and Anita owned the night.
Georgia was not over marked.
The routine was technically very difficult so the brilliance of the overall performance merited a nine or a ten.
Darcy really likes GG I concede so had it just been her that awarded them a ten you may have had a point, but it wasn't.
The judges are professional and able to critique to a standard us sitting at home cannot. They are not undermarking Jay- 9 is a brilliant score and they all agreed upon it.
Just because Jay isn't getting 10's it is a bit childish to accuse all four judges of bias.
The routine was technically very difficult so the brilliance of the overall performance merited a nine or a ten.
Darcy really likes GG I concede so had it just been her that awarded them a ten you may have had a point, but it wasn't.
The judges are professional and able to critique to a standard us sitting at home cannot. They are not undermarking Jay- 9 is a brilliant score and they all agreed upon it.
Just because Jay isn't getting 10's it is a bit childish to accuse all four judges of bias.
Originally Posted by Cornchips:
“Georgia was fab but she made a mistake so should not have got a ten. Even I noticed the mistake it was bloody obvious
Jay is always under marked. Imthinkmhei expect more from him somehow which is unfair. His salsa was brilliant.
Glad Peter finally got the mark he deserved.”
“Georgia was fab but she made a mistake so should not have got a ten. Even I noticed the mistake it was bloody obvious
Jay is always under marked. Imthinkmhei expect more from him somehow which is unfair. His salsa was brilliant.
Glad Peter finally got the mark he deserved.”
I thought in hold that was one of the best technical VW performances I can remember and delightful to watch
Not that it really matters, but my main gripe is that the judges have to be so nice to Peter when they criticise him - yet when they pick fault with Jay or Katie they just let rip. Not fair!
Forgive my cynicism but I suspect people only start moaning about judge bias when their favoured couple are deemed to have suffered as a result.
As I do not have a personal favourite couple per se I don't have this issue.
My favoured couple changes weekly based on who I think performed best and I am past caring what the judges do.
When it is all said and done I cannot change the results anyway so I am relaxed about the outcome.
As I do not have a personal favourite couple per se I don't have this issue.
My favoured couple changes weekly based on who I think performed best and I am past caring what the judges do.
When it is all said and done I cannot change the results anyway so I am relaxed about the outcome.
Originally Posted by Tejas:
“Not that it really matters, but my main gripe is that the judges have to be so nice to Peter when they criticise him - yet when they pick fault with Jay or Katie they just let rip. Not fair!”
“Not that it really matters, but my main gripe is that the judges have to be so nice to Peter when they criticise him - yet when they pick fault with Jay or Katie they just let rip. Not fair!”
They've been really horrid to Katie, some of the criticism was hard to watch
Originally Posted by pabird:
“I thought in hold that was one of the best technical VW performances I can remember and delightful to watch”
“I thought in hold that was one of the best technical VW performances I can remember and delightful to watch”
You won't know me because I didn't post last year but I was around and read the forum, and I remember your beautiful touching thread about your wife. I'm delighted you enjoyed this dance -- and I hope that you are thriving
You can tell Georgia is a real threat by some of the reaction on here and I stick by my thread they will be 1st and 2nd in any order I don't care but Georgia has some momentum going right now.
Originally Posted by JH84:
“I find them biased towards KK as well. Although the QS was really good. Kellie's show off and me me behaviour is so grating!”
“I find them biased towards KK as well. Although the QS was really good. Kellie's show off and me me behaviour is so grating!”
You mean more than Helen? If anyone is a "luvvie" it's Helen, with her fake smiles and surprised looks. She's permanently acting and if it wasn't for Aljaz I think she'd be in trouble.
Originally Posted by Dervlathedog:
“You won't know me because I didn't post last year but I was around and read the forum, and I remember your beautiful touching thread about your wife. I'm delighted you enjoyed this dance -- and I hope that you are thriving”
“You won't know me because I didn't post last year but I was around and read the forum, and I remember your beautiful touching thread about your wife. I'm delighted you enjoyed this dance -- and I hope that you are thriving”
thank you for the thought
Thriving yes with odd sad days
1 of 2
