• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
Under-marked/over-marked
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
marie67
21-11-2015
I thought that Darcey had the marking just about right tonight.
She had Anita top with the only 10 which i thought was just about right.

Undermarked:
Don't particularly think anyone was under-marked other than Anita comparatively

Overmarked:
Peter - no way deserved 8 from len & bruno
Georgia & Kellie - don't think either deserved 10 & both 9
BMLisa
21-11-2015
Overmarked - Anita (but cool with it as I feel she deserved a good over marking and I think i could be biased against stampy Paso's)
Georgia - don't get 10s for that dance.
I would say Peter but he's bottom of the table- no need to rub it in

Undermarked - Jay by miles and also Kellie although if Georgia and Anita weren't overmarked hers would be fine.
missfrankiecat
21-11-2015
Georgia, Kellie and Anita all overmarked.
Jay and Katie undermarked, Jay dramatically so and Katie in comparison to others.
Peter, Jamelia and Helen about right.
Nina_Blake
21-11-2015
Undermarked:

Kellie
Jamelia

Overmarked:

Jay
Peter
Helen
Fudd
21-11-2015
Over-marked
Anita - lacked shaping through the Paso and slipped a couple of times.
Georgia - made a mistake which was picked up on but not marked accordingly.
Kellie - was far too upright in hold.

Under-marked
No one really!
Cornchips
21-11-2015
Jay under marked

Georgia over marked. She made mistakes and still got 10s

Kellie over marked. Good but not deserving of a 10

I don't like paso so it's difficult for me to say whether Anita was over marked or under marked as I detested the whole thing.
PigsMightFly
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by marie67:
“I thought that Darcey had the marking just about right tonight.
She had Anita top with the only 10 which i thought was just about right.

Undermarked:
Don't particularly think anyone was under-marked other than Anita comparatively

Overmarked:
Peter - no way deserved 8 from len & bruno
Georgia & Kellie - don't think either deserved 10 & both 9”

I agree. Anita is consistently undermarked. Even tonight (apart from Darcy who I agree voted fairly) she should have been above Georgia who got higher marks from Len and Bruno as well as Helen who got the same marks again from Bruno and Len. Both Georgia and Helen made mistakes bur Anita's performance was flawless
Frank Mag
21-11-2015
Overmarked: All couples who got a 10, not one dance deserved a 10 ... Oh and Peter, Craig got that 6 spot on unlike last week and the other judges should have done the same

Undermarked: Jay
nyannie
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by PigsMightFly:
“I agree. Anita is consistently undermarked. Even tonight (apart from Darcy who I agree voted fairly) she should have been above Georgia who got higher marks from Len and Bruno as well as Helen who got the same marks again from Bruno and Len. Both Georgia and Helen made mistakes bur Anita's performance was flawless”

Agree - I also think Jay was undermarked. Anita should have gotten at least two more 10s and Jay should have gotten at least one.

Don't want to rub it in but Peter's dance - what was it - was overmarked - I gave him a 6.
Nina_Blake
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by Frank Mag:
“Overmarked: All couples who got a 10, not one dance deserved a 10 ... Oh and Peter, Craig got that 6 spot on unlike last week and the other judges should have done the same

Undermarked: Jay”

If not one dance deserved a 10, then how can Jay be undermarked?
bendymixer
21-11-2015
Jay undermarked

Anita although she has been undermarked throghout tonight she was overmarked dance too light in Paso steps for me
lateone
21-11-2015
Jay under marked. The perils of going on first. Worth at least 1 x10
Helen over marked. So many mistakes
Purple Mango
21-11-2015
I think the marking was overall fair (for it being Blackpool week too)
hownwbrowncow
21-11-2015
I think Kellie was very slightly over marked. Apart from that they were pretty spot on.
Frank Mag
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by Nina_Blake:
“If not one dance deserved a 10, then how can Jay be undermarked?”

I thought Craig gave him an 8, my mistake.
quique
21-11-2015
For me, it's not about individual scores anymore. But I have to say; Anita should have placed higher than Georgia on the leader board or Georgia should have placed the same as Jay.
duckylucky
21-11-2015
Peter was way overmarked . His jive was not a jive , it was awful
ladygardener
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by lateone:
“Jay under marked. The perils of going on first. Worth at least 1 x10
Helen over marked. So many mistakes”

How could the judges not notice all her mistakes. I'm no ballroom dancer but they were so obvious that I expected Craig at least to make some comments about them. I've never been to the Tower Ballroom but I wonder if the judges were just too far away to see the mistakes. Bruno made some comment but Helen and Aljaz blamed it on the table thing they were standing on.
PigsMightFly
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by nyannie:
“Agree - I also think Jay was undermarked. Anita should have gotten at least two more 10s and Jay should have gotten at least one.

Don't want to rub it in but Peter's dance - what was it - was overmarked - I gave him a 6.”

Yes I thought Jay might have got a few 10s.
Mrs Finkelstein
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by missfrankiecat:
“Georgia, Kellie and Anita all overmarked.
Jay and Katie undermarked, Jay dramatically so and Katie in comparison to others.
Peter, Jamelia and Helen about right.”

Agree with this......maybe not so much with Katie.
PigsMightFly
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by ladygardener:
“How could the judges not notice all her mistakes. I'm no ballroom dancer but they were so obvious that I expected Craig at least to make some comments about them. I've never been to the Tower Ballroom but I wonder if the judges were just too far away to see the mistakes. Bruno made some comment but Helen and Aljaz blamed it on the table thing they were standing on.”

When they were on the table she started on the wrong foot and was out of sync initially with the other dances. Bruno and Len gave her the same mark as Jay and Anita and Kelly which was baffling
ChickenFromKiev
21-11-2015
Undermarked:
Dare I say Anita?

Overmarked:
Peter, Helen, Georgia
marie67
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by duckylucky:
“Peter was way overmarked . His jive was not a jive , it was awful”

8 from both len and bruno was both surprising and confusing
Dervlathedog
21-11-2015
A question -- just for accuracy. Is Georgia's 'mistake' (sg, not pl) that everyone is mentioning a wardrobe malfunction???
walnut699
21-11-2015
Undermarked
Jamelia

Over marked
Kellie
Peter
Georgia

I think the rest were fine.
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map