• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
Under-marked/over-marked
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
Strictly_fan
21-11-2015
Overmarked:
Kellie (like way. Do not deserve a 10. Absolutely crazy)
Katie
Georgia (slightly

Undermarked:
Helen(deserved 10s across the bord)
Anita (I thought 38/39)
Jay
Peter (surprised by his marks)
Jameila was about right
Mrs Finkelstein
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by Dervlathedog:
“A question -- just for accuracy. Is Georgia's 'mistake' (sg, not pl) that everyone is mentioning a wardrobe malfunction???”

No, she stumbled coming out of a lift, then caught in her dress. Plus her frame was loose and footwork a bit messy. I like Georgia (2nd favourite) but this continual glossing over of her errors is really starting to nark me!!!
BMLisa
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by Mrs Finkelstein:
“No, she stumbled coming out of a lift, then caught in her dress. Plus her frame was loose and footwork a bit messy. I like Georgia (2nd favourite) but this continual glossing over of her errors is really starting to nark me!!!”

Thankyou.

I'm am a Jay fan but I fully believe Georgia deserves to be in the final as well as him, but it is getting a bit frustrating to see faults ignored 3 weeks in a row.
Dervlathedog
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by Mrs Finkelstein:
“No, she stumbled coming out of a lift, then caught in her dress. Plus her frame was loose and footwork a bit messy. I like Georgia (2nd favourite) but this continual glossing over of her errors is really starting to nark me!!!”

You're describing a right old mess! I'll have to watch again
tawny
21-11-2015
Overmarked

Kellie
Anita
Helen

Undermarked
Jay

Peter's jive was awful but that down to Janette - no kicks & flicks
nagel84
21-11-2015
Overmarked:
Katie, Anita and Jay.
Also Peter - although he was rightfully placed bottom of the leaderboard I'm still mystified as to how his (almost) jiveless jive managed to get two 8s.

Undermarked - No-one
The Swampster
21-11-2015
I thought Jamelia was very overmarked, and that inflated the marks of nearly everyone who came after her as they are all much better dancers. (This includes Peter, though I agree his jive this week didn't have much content and was a bit lifeless for him.)
Jay was the only one who went before Jamelia and I think his marks were about right.
ChickenFromKiev
21-11-2015
Originally Posted by Strictly_fan:
“Overmarked:
Kellie (like way. Do not deserve a 10. Absolutely crazy)
Katie
Georgia (slightly

Undermarked:
Helen(deserved 10s across the bord)
Anita (I thought 38/39)
Jay
Peter (surprised by his marks)
Jameila was about right”

What?
hannah
21-11-2015
Undermarked: Jay (should of have got a couples of 10s) Anita (deserved more than 1 10)
Overmarked: Georgia should have been 9s
marinamau
21-11-2015
If we take the first performance as a guide ie Jay was mark correctly, which I think it's about right, almost all but Kellie were overmarked. Neither of them (Kellie and Jay) had errors that I could see (mind you didn't noticed Georgia's either first time) and good content routines.

All had errors and/or wobbles, some little content (Pete looking at you, Anita too but not as bad).
purplesky99
22-11-2015
Originally Posted by The Swampster:
“I thought Jamelia was very overmarked, and that inflated the marks of nearly everyone who came after her as they are all much better dancers.”

I agree entirely. Why on earth are they marking Jamelia so highly?
tabithakitten
22-11-2015
Originally Posted by Strictly_fan:
“Overmarked:
Kellie (like way. Do not deserve a 10. Absolutely crazy)
Katie
Georgia (slightly

Undermarked:
Helen(deserved 10s across the bord)
Anita (I thought 38/39)
Jay
Peter (surprised by his marks)
Jameila was about right”

It really, really didn't...
-Sid-
22-11-2015
Overmarked:

Probably everything that got a 10, but in particular Georgia's VW.

Helen - 9s? Saw at least two obvious mistakes.

Katie - adored her but 8s would have been adequate given the wobbles.

Peter - didn't want to see anything above a 7 for that Jive.

Undermarked:

Nobody.
Heatherbell
22-11-2015
Anita undermarked . She was brilliant .
helen overmarked totally .Made lots of small errors and one huge one on the steps .
jay overmarked .It was basic, but he smiled so he got a higher score . Yep, it's that easy .
georgia undermarked massively .What does she need to do to get the correct scores fgs ! She/it was stunning in every way .
peter about right .Wasn't very jive and tragic choreography from his pro .
kellie undermarked . Dressed like one of the aunt bessie women , yet did a clean perfect lovely dance with no errors .
jamelia about right . She was better than usual but still lacking .
katie undermarked . She was fabulous .
Fred.
22-11-2015
I don't know if Anita was under or over marked. Anita herself didn't do a lot of Paso steps, but gosh it was dramatic. Anita was so graceful too.

Do wish Gleb would give Anita a bit of credit though! When she said thank you to him he didn't say anything to praise her. Then when Claudia asked him if he was proud, he said it was his favourite dance. What about Anita's hard work?!?!

Helen was a bit over-marked as several errors at the end. More noticeable on re-watching.

Jay's mark seemed OK at first, but when watched again it was even better.
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map