Originally Posted by Fudd:
“Oh not always. Remember the farcical series six semi-final when the judges tied Rachel and Lisa at the top meaning Tom couldn't be saved by the public vote?
Then there have been disrupted ones through the years - Gabby v Penny, Pixie v Simon... the show will be fine. For now. Though they could do with avoiding controversy for the rest of the series.”
I agree but, on the whole we normally get the right final - even if we don't always get the right result (
Colinwuzrobbed 
).
What is surprising is how the programme got this one so wrong. I think they were gambling on the Jamilia's lack of support to sweep the judges choice under the carpet. What they weren't expecting was the huge gap in the execution of the routines by Peter and Jamilia, to the point that even a complete novice could see she was much better than him in the DO.