When they criticised his so called jive so much when he danced in the first part of the show . Here is some of what they said

Len: "It wasn't your finest hour"

Bruno: "With all that energy you lose the style of the dance . Kicks and flicks that is what we're looking at , it has to be distinguishable . It has to be recognised as a jive ".

Then Tess asks Craig how does that compare to the other jives

Craig: "It falls at the bottom of the pack of jives . Flat footed, heavy, kicks looked odd, weight in the wrong place, lack of retraction ".

Darcey: "Weight too far back"

Having watched Peter twice do the dance, he repeated the exact same dance as the first time only worse .
How they can have the bare faced cheek to say he danced better is beyond belief .

I thought those judges were above reproach but I now see they're no more then lackeys of the producer and I'll never trust their marks again .

How many more threads saying the same thing.

Yeah see, I think this is where you overegged it, but good effort.

But it was in the script.

You beat me to it.

When they were giving their verdict, the judges didn't sound as if they were themselves convinced, or was that, "in the script?"

But none of them did actually say he was better - they just said they wanted Peter to go through. Only Darcey attempted anything resembling a justification for her "choice" (got to love air quotes!) stating that Peter had improved more based on the earlier performance, and even that was highly debateable at best.

Surely, if you want to retain any credibility as a judge you don't put someone through who was worse .

most of the Pro's have been changed over the years ,
but the 3 of the judges have remained the same ,
me thinks its time for a change ,

How many more people saying
"How many more threads saying the same thing" ?

Repetition bugs me

and I'm sure I've said that before now.

I haven't seen any mention that when Jamelia finished her dance they cut straight to Tess in a close up shot and didn't let us see the audience or the judges . When Peter finished his dance they showed the majority seated and the judges clapping . Why were the judges clapping his dance ? I wonder did they also clap when Jamelia finished her dance ..

3 more puppets for the producers to manipulate then.