Originally Posted by Philip Wales:
“^^It's not just that, it's the fact, all the episodes are there in a nice chronological order, available to watch as a binge or over a few weeks. I don't have to remember that Channel 5 has this and that, Fox has this and Living have that. The programmes are actually all going to be there for me, so I don't have to watch them all in one go etc.
A few months ago I used ITV catch up to watch the "The Unforgotten" I watched the first 4 episodes, the last 2 hadn't aired, but by the time the last 2 aired, the first 2 had dropped off catch up, so it was lucky I'd watched them and not decided to binge watch one weekend.
I've noticed BBC do it too, it's a pain and it looks like they don't really want you to use the catch up service as a "on demand" service.”
That 30 day window really needs to change, I agree.
The problem is three-fold, licensing agreements, anti competitive practices (for the BBC) and limiting sales.
The first is the easiest to solve. Hulu has been offering this on many of their shows, and sometimes All 4 and Demand 5 do as well.
The second is specifically for the BBC. The problem there is that the BBC can't be seen as too dominating (well, even more dominating than it is now). It was difficult enough for the BBC to move from their original 7 days to 30 days, and it came at the cost of that amazing binge-supporting feature - Series Link. Back when they only had 7-days to catch-up, many BBC series had something called Series Link, where they would retain every episode of a series (season) until the last one aired, and then applied 7 days for the lot.
They even had a 45 day window back then using the 7+30+7 formula. That is, seven days to download the programme (iOS or computer), plus 30 days to watch it, and a further seven days from the date of watching to re-watch it.
But believe it or not, you and I were probably the only two people who found Series Link useful back then. It was almost universally unused. (This was way back in 2014). I loved it and used it all the time.
As for the 3rd issue, that is the most difficult. Basically, in the case of FTA catch-up services, any "original" productions they have, the networks like to sell them onwards. They make more money selling them to Netflix, Prime, UKTV or even Now TV than they do by keeping them available for free via advertising revenue.
All 4 will keep old box sets, but not newer ones, and this is likely to change in the future.
I'm on your side by the way, and this is something which will improve as long as we don't mind paying in the future. What we will see is a lot more OTT services behind a paywall. That may mean that the BBC and all the FTA networks either end up having an additional paywall to access all of their content over 30 days (the US networks do this, either like CBS with a true OTT service, or the others via Hulu and cable TV), or we may see a UK version of Hulu here where this will be possible. It is unlikely it will be free in the future though.