|
||||||||
This is Most Definitely Not An Appreciation Thread - Part 23 |
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|
#16551 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 1,013
|
Quote:
the memory of Louise running towards the camera with a deranged grin like a mad auntie who'd just escaped from the attic after murdering the entire family will haunt my nights for years
![]() In my Fantasy Strictly Reverie, she did this on purpose to be subversive. |
|
|
|
|
Please sign in or register to remove this advertisement.
|
|
|
#16552 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,225
|
I feel as though Louise became PoorLouise again in that final. She ought to have been the favourite at that point, no? The one finalist going into that final without hitting the bottom two after Ore had hit it twice (and was therefore assumed to have a problem with the vote) and Danny had done so just one week before. The momentum surely ought to have been with Louise for just one final push and then... well, then she danced nicely and everyone said what a nice person she was and she said she didn't really mind about winning anyway and the whole thing felt a bit like a giant shrug. She had fun, Kevin felt like a good person for improving her confidence, the judges were all very nice to her and Louise had a jolly good time. Oh, was there meant to be a competition in there somewhere? You'd never know.
Credit to Ore and Joanne, they put their best feet forward in that final and it paid off. He had an amazing evening and I thoroughly enjoyed his dances. I will unappreciate that if he hadn't danced the jive and the AS (and, effectively, another AS for his showdance), I don't know what else he could have picked that would have gone down as well. Ore and Joanne showcased perfectly what Ore did best over four months on Strictly. Louise I think was let down slightly by dance choice - she ought to have done at least one ballroom number if we were going to see her best points and I don't think the showdance was particularly well judged, though I can see what Kevin was going for. Danny... Danny did everything. Last night he danced classic, old-fashioned ballroom (quickstep), party Latin (samba) and his showdance was as dramatic as could be (AT and Paso, as well as contemporary). Showing off what Danny could do basically meant letting him do everything. And that's why I wanted him and Oti to win. Oh well. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16553 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
Posts: 9,818
|
Quote:
I think the only one they could have pushed to the final otherwise is Claudia. The final six was made up of her, the finalists, Rob and Ed. The latter two were not strong enough to compete, plus the Judge had a complete imbalance in his dance set which meant he'd have to dance two ballroom's had he made it. The likes of Laura, Daisy and Anastacia maybe didn't develop, partially due to injury perhaps for two of the three, as much as expected and that, on top of Will's withdrawal, made the majority of the series about simply culling the herd.
|
|
|
|
|
|
#16554 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 13,160
|
Quote:
I think it's likely that that played a role, but Oti as the first black pro to win, would also have made a good story. I think, in the main, of the better dancers, these three offered what they thought would be the ideal mix: Danny the Trained and Consummate Showman; Ore the Plucky Beginner with Natural Flair; Louise the (slightly
) Older Woman Finding Herself Again After Children and Blossoming into... well, I think the well ran dry at the end, but you get the drift. Danny's story was a bit harder to push and relied on him blowing everyone away at the final hurdle, but he went a little adrift when it counted most.I guess when they are trying to attract celebs to take part it helps if the winners come from as large a pool as possible to attract as many as possible. Three perceived ringer wins on the trot had them twitchy. They needed a NDB to balance it up a bit. Now when they are pitching, they can say NDB's are not disadvantaged. Have to say, listening to Danny talking on ITT about how he had been asked to take part for 4 years, but only now felt able to be himself, I thought he actually filled Louise's storyline better than she did! |
|
|
|
|
|
#16555 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Sep 2012
Posts: 3,283
|
Quote:
Not bitter at all
I'm flippin annoyed that Jwann basically copied Tom Chambers' showdance, substituting tarting about on podia for tap dancing. I would like to see a Viewers' Choice in the final. Lowest Scoring, so we can see how much they've improved (or not), Viewers' Choice, and Showdance. And they have to dance the original routines. I would have picked Louizzzze's Cha Cha, because it was so awful, Bore's Charleston, because of the almost-drop, and Danny's American Smooth, because it was so fabulous. And Viewers choice is as ripe for manipulation as anything else. Besides, how and when would they organise it? Showdance is an awful concept, particularly the way it is done now (with most of the routines being in large part nothing to do with the ballroom or Latin skills they've learned to date) |
|
|
|
|
|
#16556 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: The North!
Posts: 2,201
|
Quote:
I just think for 2 years now they've been desperate for a NDB to win again, and this year reached almost Series 3 levels of desperation.
I guess when they are trying to attract celebs to take part it helps if the winners come from as large a pool as possible to attract as many as possible. Three perceived ringer wins on the trot had them twitchy. They needed a NDB to balance it up a bit. Now when they are pitching, they can say NDB's are not disadvantaged. Have to say, listening to Danny talking on ITT about how he had been asked to take part for 4 years, but only now felt able to be himself, I thought he actually filled Louise's storyline better than she did! |
|
|
|
|
|
#16557 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: In sunny (hah!) Yorkshire
Posts: 13,940
|
Can you tell how unappreciative I've been of the whole series that I haven't watched the final and instead decided to come here to see who won? It's been an utter bust for me this year. Although I have enjoyed individual dances from individual competitors I didn't really have a favourite at all. Quote:
I just think for 2 years now they've been desperate for a NDB to win again, and this year reached almost Series 3 levels of desperation.
|
|
|
|
|
#16558 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 6,394
|
Quote:
I'm not sure if I'm growing more cynical or the producers are becoming more manipulative but, for me, the show is becoming more and more controlled week on week, year on year. And the issue is once the producers have the taste of power they are very unwilling to let go of it.
Quote:
Well, at least TPTB appear to have listened in one respect, which is to make the judges' choices some of the best dances rather than some of the worst, thus making the final a more up-beat affair.
If I were a Louise fan, I would have been furious at the way she was sabotaged, though, with judge's choice. That's one of the reasons I think it perfectly fair for viewers to choose to base their vote on the series of the whole rather than just the final night - one or more couples can be affected by poor dance choice (Jay and Georgia last year other notable examples) "One night only" viewers will also be far more subject to judges' pimping efforts, as they will not have seen the judges adopt their favourites several weeks, or even months, back. And finally, this is a competition that has gone on for 3 months, not one night. The final is culmination and celebration (the latter aspect missing last year) of their achievements. However, people might want to vote for the person who has given them the most pleasure over 3 months, for whatever reason, not just on one night. This year, although Danny was the best dancer, he did not do himself justice in the final, but, unlike Jay last year, he evidently did not have enough goodwill accumulated from the previous 3 months to make up for it. At least he finished on a high - that samba. Wow! Quote:
The biggest surprise was Danny.
As I said back in September, I expected him to be like Mark Wright and I expected to hate him for it. Instead he turned out be be a nice bloke, not arrogant or swaggering and I enjoyed every single dance he performed. He made mistakes - which only made him seem more likeable. I thank Louise and her calm niceness because she seemed to keep Kevin down a bit. Especially in the Clauditorium. No squealng and jumping about during the scores much. Well, certainly less than last year with Kellie Bright. So I thank her for that. Now I await the appointment of Len's replacement with eager anticipation. Kevin was never more tolerable. I'm hoping for a week one exit next year - we've had 4 years with him in every single episode and it's just too much. I'm hoping for someone completely new. Not Darcey, Craig or Bruno promoted, not Karen, not Brendan or Anton. Not Papa Clifton! But a fresh face would be nice. Quote:
As long as I never have to see a week one tango in the final again, I'm happy
![]() Did feel for Louise, though. Rotten pick for her on every level. Am still a bit baffled by how she can have such a floppy core after 4 months, though ![]() Frankly, the floppy core has me wondering how hard she worked. It really should be better than that. Her equilibrium was awful in that AT. Quote:
Louise was hung out to dry with her cha cha but as she won the cha cha challenge maybe the judges thought she would be brilliant dancing around in her knickers in the final. Couple that with a poor choice of showdance and she was toast.
Don't do contemporary in the final Kevin and Oti. Only person to get away with it was Jay. Joanne pitched it right with two showdances and a crowd pleasing jive. Credit to her [said through gritted teeth] I loved Oti and Danny's showdance but maybe too angst for the final and the casual viewer. Jay, Caroline, and I think Louis. But contempowaft has to be heartfelt if it has any hope of winning. Yes, Jwann made the right choice. Slightly unfair to have two showdances, but it appealed to viewers. Oti? QS was (like Ore's AS) a gift, but perhaps as mimi (I think) said last night, the samba looked to new viewers like just a bit of shaking about? Ditto the showdance. Quote:
I find it incredibly sad to be honest. I do like to invest in people to an extent but when you feel its been pre-determined at what point they are going to leave, what's the point? I supported Judge Rinder all the way but felt defeated in his last week and voted more out of habit than anything.
I don't really know what will happen and how I will feel about it next year, but I really hope they start losing viewers - the whole '10 million people are happy so don't change it' schtick is beyond tiring. SCD is badly broken and I fear if they carry on like this it could be terminal, or a show that anyone who takes dancing even vaguely seriously cannot stomach. I've had a lot going on this year so didn't get into the show as much. I looked at the show more cynically (also following last year, which was just odd - very popular winner, extremely gifted dancer, and yet they threw their efforts behind a contestant many found deeply annoying?!) and it's a bit unpleasant at times. Quote:
I wonder how much say the couples actually have for their showdances? We had a ballroom based, Latin based and contempwaft and if Clowider had been fourth slot then there would have been a acrobatic based one. All bases neatly covered.
Quote:
Not bitter at all
I'm flippin annoyed that Jwann basically copied Tom Chambers' showdance, substituting tarting about on podia for tap dancing. I would like to see a Viewers' Choice in the final. Lowest Scoring, so we can see how much they've improved (or not), Viewers' Choice, and Showdance. And they have to dance the original routines. I would have picked Louizzzze's Cha Cha, because it was so awful, Bore's Charleston, because of the almost-drop, and Danny's American Smooth, because it was so fabulous. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16559 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 6,394
|
Quote:
yeah I agree...just WHY do you think it was soooooo important for the finalists to be those three? I mean I PREDICTED IT 5 WEEKS AGO...YOU COULD SENSE WHO THE JOOODGES WANTED THERE... but was it for balance that they wanted Ore as the 'third' man in the final....or was there something more political at large, considering some of the early exits and the criticism those exits gained from some quarters on here?
Quote:
I just think for 2 years now they've been desperate for a NDB to win again, and this year reached almost Series 3 levels of desperation.
I guess when they are trying to attract celebs to take part it helps if the winners come from as large a pool as possible to attract as many as possible. Three perceived ringer wins on the trot had them twitchy. They needed a NDB to balance it up a bit. Now when they are pitching, they can say NDB's are not disadvantaged. Have to say, listening to Danny talking on ITT about how he had been asked to take part for 4 years, but only now felt able to be himself, I thought he actually filled Louise's storyline better than she did! |
|
|
|
|
|
#16560 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Sep 2012
Posts: 3,283
|
Quote:
Voting for who is best in the final is valid, as is voting for the one you thought better over the series - or, if a comedy dancer were ever allowed near the final, the one you found most entertaining. What I disliked about last night was how Louise was so clearly dumped, and all the impetus put behind Ore to win over people who were only watching the final. My feeling is that she had the best/most consistent vote throughout the series, but the bus was reversed over her last night
I've had a lot going on this year so didn't get into the show as much. I looked at the show more cynically (also following last year, which was just odd - very popular winner, extremely gifted dancer, and yet they threw their efforts behind a contestant many found deeply annoying?!) and it's a bit unpleasant at times. I'd be curious to know who wins most on Tour - Ore, Danny or Ed! |
|
|
|
|
|
#16561 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: The North!
Posts: 2,201
|
Quote:
I think it's likely that that played a role, but Oti as the first black pro to win, would also have made a good story. I think, in the main, of the better dancers, these three offered what they thought would be the ideal mix: Danny the Trained and Consummate Showman; Ore the Plucky Beginner with Natural Flair; Louise the (slightly
) Older Woman Finding Herself Again After Children and Blossoming into... well, I think the well ran dry at the end, but you get the drift. Danny's story was a bit harder to push and relied on him blowing everyone away at the final hurdle, but he went a little adrift when it counted most. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16562 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 80,211
|
Unappreciating Oti for choreographing a showdance that had NO still moments and no subtlety at all.
Frantic, odd mess, though dramatic. She should have done better there, she took 'showbiz to hide faults' too far, and it was a mess. Misjudged. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16563 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 13,160
|
Quote:
I don't think he got there for those reasons. But they love the narrative of NDB...
Exactly this. They knew NDB is a narrative that if they are even a bit decent, will carry someone a long time. I think the big push next year will be female, but sportsperson could also be a big thing. Cloudier was a year too early!
|
|
|
|
|
|
#16564 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: The North!
Posts: 2,201
|
Quote:
Unappreciating Oti for choreographing a showdance that had NO still moments and no subtlety at all.
Frantic, odd mess, though dramatic. She should have done better there, she took 'showbiz to hide faults' too far, and it was a mess. Misjudged. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16565 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 80,211
|
Quote:
Personally I thought it was fabulous. I like contemporary dance though and I can see that to win the floating voters you probably need to do something more ballroom/traditional. I think TTF going all contempowaft is what lost them the glitterball. Basically, theirs was a Bonnie Tyler video circa 1986 with TTF lifting Louise around for 2 minutes.
And it seemed to make her happy, and she only really had votes to carry her. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16566 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 13,043
|
Quote:
Ohhhh!
Dangling above the abyss! Quote:
Unappreciating Oti for choreographing a showdance that had NO still moments and no subtlety at all.
Frantic, odd mess, though dramatic. She should have done better there, she took 'showbiz to hide faults' too far, and it was a mess. Misjudged. Oti is a great choreographer, but she needs to show a bit more light and shade, rather throwing everything including kitchen sink PLUS food waste disposal unit at the dance. On the other hand, Kevin showed plenty of quiet moments in their Showdance, but sadly very little else |
|
|
|
|
|
#16567 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Sep 2012
Posts: 3,283
|
Quote:
I have a suspicion that Kevin did what Louise wanted and made her happy, and sod it.
And it seemed to make her happy, and she only really had votes to carry her. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16568 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 80,211
|
Quote:
I personally loved their Showdance (for all the Zoe's "we were all in tears" it's one of the few dances that actually gave me goosebumps) but I understand you wanting a few moments of quiet as a contrast.
Oti is a great choreographer, but she needs to show a bit more light and shade, rather throwing everything including kitchen sink PLUS food waste disposal unit at the dance. On the other hand, Kevin showed plenty of quiet moments in their Showdance, but sadly very little else And actually didn't think he'd win, nor worried about it. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16569 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 13,160
|
Quote:
Yup. Much like Chelsee having to do a disco number vs. Harry Latin and Jason Ballroom...
|
|
|
|
|
|
#16570 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: The North!
Posts: 2,201
|
Quote:
I personally loved their Showdance (for all the Zoe's "we were all in tears" it's one of the few dances that actually gave me goosebumps) but I understand you wanting a few moments of quiet as a contrast.
Oti is a great choreographer, but she needs to show a bit more light and shade, rather throwing everything including kitchen sink PLUS food waste disposal unit at the dance. On the other hand, Kevin showed plenty of quiet moments in their Showdance, but sadly very little else For me, it showed that you can use a prop and have it be part of the dance, not something to disguise bad dancing or fill up some time. The mirror was integral and I love that they actually told a story in their showdance and not "Here's some dry ice and a bit of wafting!" or "Here's a bit of generic ballroom and a giant drumkit..." |
|
|
|
|
|
#16571 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 13,043
|
I'm sitting here (admittedly after at least a bottle and a half of prosecco) thinking back on this series.
Strictly is ostensibly about zlebs "learning to dance" But the three finalists, good as they were, had they REALLY progressed all that far? Danny and Louise, stage school alumni. Started off adequate. Finished ever so slightly better. Louise's big journey of self discovery turned out to be "here are my knees" Never danced before Ore? Well, Joanne must have worked bloody hard with him the the three weeks between launch show and first competitive show, because he was good from the get go. But did he actually improve that much in 16 weeks?? |
|
|
|
|
|
#16572 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 80,211
|
Quote:
I'm sitting here (admittedly after at least a bottle and a half of prosecco) thinking back on this series.
Strictly is ostensibly about zlebs "learning to dance" But the three finalists, good as they were, had they REALLY progressed all that far? Danny and Louise, stage school alumni. Started off adequate. Finished ever so slightly better. Louise's big journey of self discovery turned out to be "here are my knees" Never danced before Ore? Well, Joanne must have worked bloody hard with him the the three weeks between launch show and first competitive show, because he was good from the get go. But did he actually improve that much in 16 weeks?? He wasn't always spot on tech wise until the final, and it was in dances he was natural at. Don't see it as an issue myself. He improved massively overall. The jive was energetic and exciting the first time, the second he had the tech DOWN. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16573 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: The North!
Posts: 2,201
|
Quote:
I'm sitting here (admittedly after at least a bottle and a half of prosecco) thinking back on this series.
Strictly is ostensibly about zlebs "learning to dance" But the three finalists, good as they were, had they REALLY progressed all that far? Danny and Louise, stage school alumni. Started off adequate. Finished ever so slightly better. Louise's big journey of self discovery turned out to be "here are my knees" Never danced before Ore? Well, Joanne must have worked bloody hard with him the the three weeks between launch show and first competitive show, because he was good from the get go. But did he actually improve that much in 16 weeks?? He was a natural in the latin (as evidenced by his brilliant Week 1 Cha Cha Cha) but I feel like his biggest work was in the ballroom and he obviously really had to work on that. I think Danny actually had the biggest journey (along with Claudia) because as he was so good Week 1, they started to mark him as a pro and picked up on tiny little things. |
|
|
|
|
|
#16574 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 15,052
|
Quote:
It's kinda like what TTF did with Kellie last year - the redo Charleston and the lindyhop showdance. It's canny because it cuts down the time spent having to teach and gives more time for the polish.
I did find it amusing that all the showdances were of the 'What I've learnt this Autumn' variety in various genres and even for Len this is now A Very Good Thing. Hope OurLeona was throwing peanuts at the tele. Plus it was cool 😎 |
|
|
|
|
|
#16575 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 15,052
|
Quote:
I personally loved their Showdance (for all the Zoe's "we were all in tears" it's one of the few dances that actually gave me goosebumps) but I understand you wanting a few moments of quiet as a contrast.
Oti is a great choreographer, but she needs to show a bit more light and shade, rather throwing everything including kitchen sink PLUS food waste disposal unit at the dance. On the other hand, Kevin showed plenty of quiet moments in their Showdance, but sadly very little else Everything was strength and power TBH and they did come across a bit one dimensional (power strength and ferocity). Even the VW and Foxtrot were powerful battles between them. Very dramatic but I can see why people were left wanting. It's a shame they swerved the Waltz as that could have given the still moments we never really had. |
|
|
|
![]() |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 07:13.





) Older Woman Finding Herself Again After Children and Blossoming into... well, I think the well ran dry at the end, but you get the drift. Danny's story was a bit harder to push and relied on him blowing everyone away at the final hurdle, but he went a little adrift when it counted most.
I'm flippin annoyed that Jwann basically copied Tom Chambers' showdance, substituting tarting about on podia for tap dancing.

