Originally Posted by Fudd:
“I'm not sure if I'm growing more cynical or the producers are becoming more manipulative but, for me, the show is becoming more and more controlled week on week, year on year. And the issue is once the producers have the taste of power they are very unwilling to let go of it.”
For me, both. It's one of the reasons that I'm actually starting to look forward to the Irish DWTS - for all that I expect it to be very frequently cringey, at least it might not be so manipulated.
Originally Posted by Toasted Toad:
“Well, at least TPTB appear to have listened in one respect, which is to make the judges' choices some of the best dances rather than some of the worst, thus making the final a more up-beat affair.
If I were a Louise fan, I would have been furious at the way she was sabotaged, though, with judge's choice.
That's one of the reasons I think it perfectly fair for viewers to choose to base their vote on the series of the whole rather than just the final night - one or more couples can be affected by poor dance choice (Jay and Georgia last year other notable examples)
"One night only" viewers will also be far more subject to judges' pimping efforts, as they will not have seen the judges adopt their favourites several weeks, or even months, back.
And finally, this is a competition that has gone on for 3 months, not one night. The final is culmination and celebration (the latter aspect missing last year) of their achievements. However, people might want to vote for the person who has given them the most pleasure over 3 months, for whatever reason, not just on one night.
This year, although Danny was the best dancer, he did not do himself justice in the final, but, unlike Jay last year, he evidently did not have enough goodwill accumulated from the previous 3 months to make up for it. At least he finished on a high - that samba. Wow!”
Voting for who is best in the final is valid, as is voting for the one you thought better over the series - or, if a comedy dancer were ever allowed near the final, the one you found most entertaining. What I disliked about last night was how Louise was so clearly dumped, and all the impetus put behind Ore to win over people who were only watching the final. My feeling is that she had the best/most consistent vote throughout the series, but the bus was reversed over her last night.
Originally Posted by chitarivera:
“The biggest surprise was Danny.
As I said back in September, I expected him to be like Mark Wright and I expected to hate him for it. Instead he turned out be be a nice bloke, not arrogant or swaggering and I enjoyed every single dance he performed. He made mistakes - which only made him seem more likeable.
I thank Louise and her calm niceness because she seemed to keep Kevin down a bit. Especially in the Clauditorium. No squealng and jumping about during the scores much. Well, certainly less than last year with Kellie Bright.
So I thank her for that.
Now I await the appointment of Len's replacement with eager anticipation.”
I like Danny. I expected some level of arrogance or self-awareness, but he turned out to be very nice, not a camera hog, and supportive of the other celebs. All round decent bloke - perhaps not the most engaging though.
Kevin was never more tolerable. I'm hoping for a week one exit next year - we've had 4 years with him in every single episode and it's just too much.
I'm hoping for someone completely new. Not Darcey, Craig or Bruno promoted, not Karen, not Brendan or Anton. Not Papa Clifton! But a fresh face would be nice.
Originally Posted by
aggs:
“As long as I never have to see a week one tango in the final again, I'm happy 
Did feel for Louise, though. Rotten pick for her on every level.
Am still a bit baffled by how she can have such a floppy core after 4 months, though
”
Never again see another week one anything in the final! I don't care how much they get polished, they are week one for a reason.
Frankly, the floppy core has me wondering how hard she worked. It really should be better than that. Her equilibrium was awful in that AT.
Originally Posted by smude:
“Louise was hung out to dry with her cha cha but as she won the cha cha challenge maybe the judges thought she would be brilliant dancing around in her knickers in the final. Couple that with a poor choice of showdance and she was toast.
Don't do contemporary in the final Kevin and Oti. Only person to get away with it was Jay.
Joanne pitched it right with two showdances and a crowd pleasing jive. Credit to her [said through gritted teeth]
I loved Oti and Danny's showdance but maybe too angst for the final and the casual viewer.”
... but most viewers wouldn't have picked her as the winner of the challenge. I thought there were glimpses of her enjoying it first time round, amidst the mortification. That was never going to change.
Jay, Caroline, and I think Louis. But contempowaft has to be heartfelt if it has any hope of winning.
Yes, Jwann made the right choice. Slightly unfair to have two showdances, but it appealed to viewers. Oti? QS was (like Ore's AS) a gift, but perhaps as mimi (I think) said last night, the samba looked to new viewers like just a bit of shaking about? Ditto the showdance.
Originally Posted by Tejas:
“I find it incredibly sad to be honest. I do like to invest in people to an extent but when you feel its been pre-determined at what point they are going to leave, what's the point? I supported Judge Rinder all the way but felt defeated in his last week and voted more out of habit than anything.
I don't really know what will happen and how I will feel about it next year, but I really hope they start losing viewers - the whole '10 million people are happy so don't change it' schtick is beyond tiring. SCD is badly broken and I fear if they carry on like this it could be terminal, or a show that anyone who takes dancing even vaguely seriously cannot stomach.”
They have got very good at engineering exits. Look at Ed, at JR. Samba to music that was so slow even Oksana looked placed etc. That's just one example, but we see it from early on, with bad music choices etc.
I've had a lot going on this year so didn't get into the show as much. I looked at the show more cynically (also following last year, which was just odd - very popular winner, extremely gifted dancer, and yet they threw their efforts behind a contestant many found deeply annoying?!) and it's a bit unpleasant at times.
Originally Posted by aggs:
“I wonder how much say the couples actually have for their showdances? We had a ballroom based, Latin based and contempwaft and if Clowider had been fourth slot then there would have been a acrobatic based one. All bases neatly covered.”
Yup. Much like Chelsee having to do a disco number vs. Harry Latin and Jason Ballroom...
Originally Posted by
Wiskas2:
“Not bitter at all
I'm flippin annoyed that Jwann basically copied Tom Chambers' showdance, substituting tarting about on podia for tap dancing.
I would like to see a Viewers' Choice in the final. Lowest Scoring, so we can see how much they've improved (or not), Viewers' Choice, and Showdance. And they have to dance the original routines. I would have picked Louizzzze's Cha Cha, because it was so awful, Bore's Charleston, because of the almost-drop, and Danny's American Smooth, because it was so fabulous.”
Nah, not Lowest Scoring. Week one crap. But Viewers' Choice wouldn't be too bad - would at least be popular routines. Or get them to do a dance that one of the others did, would be an interesting comparison.