• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
SCD-Semi Final Discussion Thread (Sat 12/12 6:50 & Sun 13/12 7:20)
<<
<
69 of 69
>>
>
fredster
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by brendans babe:
“But its all down to the public next week and a lot of people would love Anton to win after being there from the beginning!”

Anton has had some pretty awful partners in the past few years. He deserves a decent partner and at last a place in the final.
Saturn
13-12-2015
5 + 2 = 7 Kellie
4 + 5 = 9 Jay
4 + 3 = 7 Georgia
3 + 1 = 4 Anita
2 + 4 = 6 Katie

Katie could have been as high as 2nd on the vote
fredster
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by QwaarJet:
“She made 2 mistakes in the arm section at the beginning.

Stop the conspiracy theories.”

Isn't amazing how some of the posters on here appear to be trained dancers. They seem to know more about dancing than the professionals .
Annsyre
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by Saturn:
“5 + 2 = 7 Kellie
4 + 5 = 9 Jay
4 + 3 = 7 Georgia
3 + 1 = 5 Anita
2 + 4 = 6 Katie

Katie could have been as high as 2nd on the vote ”

Ah now I see what you mean.
northgirl
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by ads84:
“I was worried that the audience vote might've saved K+A from the DO tonight. They could be indicative of next week's votes.
K+A scored 2 in the judges points. This means that, because they were in the DO they must've scored less altogether than G+G and J+A who scored 4 each.

Say K+A got the most audience votes - they'd have 7 points.
J+A could've got the second most - total 8 points.
And G+G third - total 7 points. This would've placed them (or K+K for that matter) in the DO because if there's a tie on total points, they go with most viewer points to break the tie.

No, I don't think they can have got over the third most viewer vote. This would give them 5 points. Which means Kellie, Jay and Georgia could've got most, second most and fourth most viewer votes in whatever order without K+A being safe.

All ifs and buts of course, but this stuff keeps my brain ticking whilst I wait for the final! ”

Might not be likely but if scores were as follows:
A&K 2 + 4 = 6
A&G 3 + 1 = 4
K&K 5 + 2 = 7
G&G 4 + 3 = 7
J&A 4 + 5 = 9

Katie and Anton could have been 2nd with public although I think a different scenario is more likely as Gleb and Anita would have been bottom.
ads84
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by fredster:
“Anton has had some pretty awful partners in the past few years. He deserves a decent partner and at last a place in the final.”

But does Anton actually deserve to win?
He is obviously excellent at ballroom but his Latin and some of the more specialist dances are ropey at best. This means that he cannot keep up with the rest of the pro cast for the majority of the dances.
His awful partners are the reason he has been kept on for the show. He is the older woman's buffer. What other dancer of almost 50 years old would have a place?
I don't think he particularly deserves the place; regardless of who his partner is. He is smug and seems to think the competition is all about him, rather than the celebrity partner he supposed to showcase. I cringe every time someone mentions how far Anton has reached - it's Katie who has made it this far.
He needs to learn how to deflect attention to his partner and be much more self effacing.
Chris1964
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by ads84:
“But does Anton actually deserve to win?
He is obviously excellent at ballroom but his Latin and some of the more specialist dances are ropey at best. This means that he cannot keep up with the rest of the pro cast for the majority of the dances.
His awful partners are the reason he has been kept on for the show. He is the older woman's buffer. What other dancer of almost 50 years old would have a place?
I don't think he particularly deserves the place; regardless of who his partner is. He is smug and seems to think the competition is all about him, rather than the celebrity partner he supposed to showcase. I cringe every time someone mentions how far Anton has reached - it's Katie who has made it this far.
He needs to learn how to deflect attention to his partner and be much more self effacing.”

There is an affection towards him from the public relative to Strictly history. Katie has done well but the public will know that she doesn't deserve to win (barring something extraordinary on the night) and will vote accordingly imo.
ads84
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by Chris1964:
“There is an affection towards him from the public relative to Strictly history. Katie has done well but the public will know that she doesn't deserve to win (barring something extraordinary on the night) and will vote accordingly imo.”

There's no affection here.
I recognise Strictly history, but to be honest Brendan represents this more than Anton. He is the original winner and he continues to perform well in all areas, producing amazing choreography at times.
Annsyre
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by fredster:
“Isn't amazing how some of the posters on here appear to be trained dancers. They seem to know more about dancing than the professionals .”

Not amazing at all. I expect that the show attracts dancers and dance teachers. I have learned a lot from their comments.
Annsyre
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by ads84:
“There's no affection here.
I recognise Strictly history, but to be honest Brendan represents this more than Anton. He is the original winner and he continues to perform well in all areas, producing amazing choreography at times.”

Brendan went through a black period before he calmed down.
ads84
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by Annsyre:
“Brendan went through a black period before he calmed down.”

You're right, he did.
He hasn't always had the best of times with his partners, but he is fiercely determined to do well and produce the best dances. He is still one of Strictly's better pros, whereas Anton is a bloody joke.

Ohhh! My 7k!
Annsyre
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by ads84:
“You're right, he did.
He hasn't always had the best of times with his partners, but he is fiercely determined to do well and produce the best dances. He is still one of Strictly's better pros, whereas Anton is a bloody joke.

Ohhh! My 7k! ”

I like Anton and I like Brendan too.

Congratulations.
k9fan
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by ads84:
“There's no affection here.
I recognise Strictly history, but to be honest Brendan represents this more than Anton. He is the original winner and he continues to perform well in all areas, producing amazing choreography at times.”

Agreed, and it was a joy to watch Brendan dancing this evening.
Domestos
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by Rhumbatugger:
“The whole dance was still terrible. Untidy dismounts from the godawful lifts, legs all over the shop, flexed feet, and terrible choreo from start to finish.

It was only ever going to beat Katie if she had totally mucked up, because it was a poor offering to start with, with hardly any salsa.”

One judge disagreed with the others and you regarding who they thought deserved to stay in the competition..

I would disagree that the dance was terrible, it was very entertaining and Anita is a better all around dancer to Katie.
brendans babe
13-12-2015
Originally Posted by ads84:
“There's no affection here.
I recognise Strictly history, but to be honest Brendan represents this more than Anton. He is the original winner and he continues to perform well in all areas, producing amazing choreography at times.”

Originally Posted by Annsyre:
“Brendan went through a black period before he calmed down.”

Originally Posted by ads84:
“You're right, he did.
He hasn't always had the best of times with his partners, but he is fiercely determined to do well and produce the best dances. He is still one of Strictly's better pros, whereas Anton is a bloody joke.

Ohhh! My 7k! ”

Originally Posted by Annsyre:
“I like Anton and I like Brendan too.

Congratulations.”

Originally Posted by k9fan:
“Agreed, and it was a joy to watch Brendan dancing this evening.”

OMG a little bit of love shown on the main forum for Brendan, this almost never happens! I think i will have to save this somewhere!


Congrats Ads on 7kg!
Fudd
13-12-2015
I mentioned earlier Dancing with the Stars doing a routine shot with just one camera. This is it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Rgczhv9Bgk&=
performingmonk
14-12-2015
No surprise that they got rid of Anita. They need less competition for glorious Jay in the final...
Isobel_Donaldso
14-12-2015
I don't mind who wins this year.

Katie did look uncomfortable in the Charleston but their waltz to one of Puccini's arias was just lovely to watch - even with the mistakes. And well done to whoever sang that; some treacherous high notes for someone I'm guessing isn't opera trained.

For me, Anita was let down by her partner's choreography which was more acrobatic than dance but she gave it everything she had, as she did every week.. Didn't care for her costume at all - wedge boots?

So. Good luck to the final four. Sorry. Eight.
kwynne42
14-12-2015
Originally Posted by basdfg:
“I presume Craig wants or has been ordered to be nasty and low to put Katie in the final. Unless he is just thick and doesn't realise being nasty to someone always gains them votes.”

Or maybe he just hated the dance.
daziechain
14-12-2015
Originally Posted by Saturn:
“5 + 2 = 7 Kellie
4 + 5 = 9 Jay
4 + 3 = 7 Georgia
3 + 1 = 4 Anita
2 + 4 = 6 Katie

Katie could have been as high as 2nd on the vote ”

Is it likely that Anita came last in the public vote? After she was saved the week before.
kwynne42
15-12-2015
Originally Posted by jiroos:
“Jay & Aliona - Sorry, I didn't like the routine at all - 6/10

10??? Bruno - I think you've lost it buddy!

Maybe not - Jay is the chosen one to win after all.”

According to this thread Jay, Georgia, Kellie and Katie is the chosen one, so at least some people are going to be right.
kwynne42
15-12-2015
Originally Posted by Logopolis:
“Georgia will probably get a 40”

Originally Posted by Fudd:
“Here comes the 40.”

I know its long past time but what makes anyone think Craig is going to give ANYONE a 10 this series, not showing any sign of doing so.
Fred.
15-12-2015
Originally Posted by northgirl:
“Might not be likely but if scores were as follows:
A&K 2 + 4 = 6
A&G 3 + 1 = 4
K&K 5 + 2 = 7
G&G 4 + 3 = 7
J&A 4 + 5 = 9

Katie and Anton could have been 2nd with public although I think a different scenario is more likely as Gleb and Anita would have been bottom.”

Have thought that having a dance-off when it's down to 5 couples gives the judges too much power compared to the public vote. It's also not good for the show as a popular contestant can end up leaving.

As you've said it is in theory possible - regardless of the likelihood - for someone to be as high as 2nd in the public voting, still be in the dance-off and end up leaving the competition.
Rogana Josh
19-12-2015
Originally Posted by Annsyre:
“Not amazing at all. I expect that the show attracts dancers and dance teachers. I have learned a lot from their comments.”

Wrists, darling! Mind those fingers!
<<
<
69 of 69
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map