Think it was the 2010 version of this thread where I last posted. Did some good work back then going from 24st down to 17-something over the course of 7 or 8 months. This time of year came around, with the cooler weather and it made me want to eat comfort food and go back to my old ways.
Piled on much of the weight again and then in 2011 someone who remembered me from that 2010 thread sent me a private message. She proposed that we should both give it another go, keeping each other motivated and informed of our progress. My heart wasn't really in it and I was an arsehole to her. When I began to struggle there were feelings of shame and embarrassment but I shouldn't have done what I did, which was to start ignoring her messages until she stopped sending them. Really regret that and I'm sorry for what I did.
It's took me until this year to give it another proper crack. Was up to my highest ever weight of 26st 7lbs when starting in February. Currently 19st 12lbs. Was good to dip under the 20st figure the past week or so. Things are going well in general and hoping to drop around another stone before Christmas.
In 2010 it was 2000 calories a day, diet like a bodybuilder with loads of protein. Was lifting weights and doing daily cardiovascular exercise. Motivation was mostly wanting to look better.
This year it started at 2000 calories again, no particular focus on protein, carbs or fat but just trying to eat reasonably healthy. Home-cooked meals, lots veggies on them etc. Found myself dropping that calorie total as the year has gone on a bit and and eat anywhere between 1500-1800 a day at the moment. Exercise is just walking, upped it to 4 miles a day from 3 a couple of weeks ago. Motivation is mostly wanting to do certain outdoorsy things more easily. I want to do a lot of walking, hiking and even some climbing next year. Perhaps do a walking holiday carrying a tent on my back, or a cycling one.
Like to think that my motivation is a better one this time around as it's something solid and tangible I want to do. The diet feels more satisfying as it's much more varied and the exercise regime has been less punishing. Hopefully all that will keep me going in the colder months better than it did back in 2010.
Going mad for up to 2 weeks at Christmas no matter what and will be stuffing my face.

Then it'll be time to get back on it. So yes, trying to get another stone off or so before then.
Originally Posted by 1manonthebog:
“I can remember this happening the first time I dieted in January and wonder does it happen to anyone else? Basically in January I ate at 1600-1700 cals per day, the scales never budged the entire month of January then first week of Feb BOOM something like 12lbs of it 1 go. A similar thing seems to be happening this time around. I started this diet over a week ago, I've not lost as much as 1 Oz. It would be easy to see why some folk give up. Does this happen to you?”
Not at the start for me, but I have had periods of time like that within the whole process. Last one has just finished. Was stuck at the same weight for 3 or 4 weeks and in the last 10 days they've shown an 8lb loss. It just happens from time to time.
Not sure why it happens. Just got to keep the doing the good things and eventually it will show on the scales too. Good luck!