I would have chose
Katie- Rumba
Jay- Foxtrot
Georgia- Samba
Kellie- Paso Doble
Katie- Rumba
Jay- Foxtrot
Georgia- Samba
Kellie- Paso Doble
what dances should have been done as Judges Choice
Katie& Anton Quickstep
Jay& Aliona Quickstep
Georgia& Giovani Rumba
Kellie& Kevin Cha-Cha-Cha or Waltz
Jay& Aliona Quickstep
Georgia& Giovani Rumba
Kellie& Kevin Cha-Cha-Cha or Waltz
Originally Posted by BeeBumble:
“Georiga - Samba
Jay - Waltz
Katie - Tango
Kellie - Foxtrot”
“Georiga - Samba
Jay - Waltz
Katie - Tango
Kellie - Foxtrot”
I like this selection.
Katie - rumba/tango (VW for favourite choice)
Georgia - samba (charleston for fav)
Jay - paso/charleston (tango for fav)
Kellie - honestly don't know???
For me, the judges choice should be a dance that was really good, but just needing tweaking (mistakes rectified or technique honed) to make it brilliant.
Then the final should just be all about fabulous dances and a great show to watch.
Georgia - samba (charleston for fav)
Jay - paso/charleston (tango for fav)
Kellie - honestly don't know???
For me, the judges choice should be a dance that was really good, but just needing tweaking (mistakes rectified or technique honed) to make it brilliant.
Then the final should just be all about fabulous dances and a great show to watch.
Originally Posted by JaysMum:
“I would have chose
Katie- Rumba
Jay- Foxtrot
Georgia- Samba
Kellie- Paso Doble”
“I would have chose
Katie- Rumba
Jay- Foxtrot
Georgia- Samba
Kellie- Paso Doble”
Do you have any criteria to detrmine who shall do what dance?
Originally Posted by Amaluna:
“Do you have any criteria to detrmine who shall do what dance?”
“Do you have any criteria to detrmine who shall do what dance?”
dances which were good but could be better/have the mistake made taken out
Originally Posted by JaysMum:
“dances which were good but could be better/have the mistake made taken out”
“dances which were good but could be better/have the mistake made taken out”
What were the mistakes in Georgi's samba or Kellie's Paso? Really, mistakes?
Originally Posted by Amaluna:
“What were the mistakes in Georgi's samba or Kellie's Paso? Really, mistakes?”
“What were the mistakes in Georgi's samba or Kellie's Paso? Really, mistakes?”
Georgias samba had a couple of Minor errors. The main one being positional one when ther were with their backs to the judges, and was quickly solved by Goovanni. Don't think the judges saw it.
Judges' choice dances for me are great dances with obvious flaws that could be sensational if done over. So, by that criteria:
Georgia - Samba (there's a bit in the middle where she loses it)
Jay - (if they were allowed to do semi-final dances) Charleston (to sort out that really bad lift)
Katie - Tango (couple of week 2 sticky moments they could have ironed out)
Kellie - ehhhhhhh maybe the Jive?
Georgia - Samba (there's a bit in the middle where she loses it)
Jay - (if they were allowed to do semi-final dances) Charleston (to sort out that really bad lift)
Katie - Tango (couple of week 2 sticky moments they could have ironed out)
Kellie - ehhhhhhh maybe the Jive?
Originally Posted by marinamau:
“Georgias samba had a couple of Minor errors. The main one being positional one when ther were with their backs to the judges, and was quickly solved by Goovanni. Don't think the judges saw it.”
“Georgias samba had a couple of Minor errors. The main one being positional one when ther were with their backs to the judges, and was quickly solved by Goovanni. Don't think the judges saw it.”
My point.
So if we have to be fair, I don't think Georgia has that much to improve on that Samba.
Georgia : Quickstep
Jay : Waltz
Katie : Rumba
Kellie : Foxtrot
Under the following rules :
Opposite genre to Contestants Choice
Didn't get any 10s
Wasn't over-themed
Wasn't crap
Which I think keeps the spirit of the round, even if I'd rather they just let the contestants choose whatever two dances they want.
Jay : Waltz
Katie : Rumba
Kellie : Foxtrot
Under the following rules :
Opposite genre to Contestants Choice
Didn't get any 10s
Wasn't over-themed
Wasn't crap
Which I think keeps the spirit of the round, even if I'd rather they just let the contestants choose whatever two dances they want.
Originally Posted by Monkseal:
“Georgia : Quickstep
Jay : Waltz
Katie : Rumba
Kellie : Foxtrot
Under the following rules :
Opposite genre to Contestants Choice
Didn't get any 10s
Wasn't over-themed
Wasn't crap
Which I think keeps the spirit of the round, even if I'd rather they just let the contestants choose whatever two dances they want.”
“Georgia : Quickstep
Jay : Waltz
Katie : Rumba
Kellie : Foxtrot
Under the following rules :
Opposite genre to Contestants Choice
Didn't get any 10s
Wasn't over-themed
Wasn't crap
Which I think keeps the spirit of the round, even if I'd rather they just let the contestants choose whatever two dances they want.”
BIB totally.
I like your rules, they make sense.
To be fair I think in the case of Georgia, Jay & Katie the judges choices were spot on, I confess to only remembering a few of Kellie's best ones which probably didn't need too much improvement!!
Certainly I would not for the world have missed seeing that final Rumba from Geo & Gio! I loved the first version but the second was just unbelievable & such an improvement (still irks me it didn't get 10s!!!!!
)
Jay's quickstep obviously had room for improvement and to be fair it did improve a lot, likewise Katie's QS!!
Certainly I would not for the world have missed seeing that final Rumba from Geo & Gio! I loved the first version but the second was just unbelievable & such an improvement (still irks me it didn't get 10s!!!!!
)Jay's quickstep obviously had room for improvement and to be fair it did improve a lot, likewise Katie's QS!!
