End of Season Review!!
Caveats:
I've mainly watched on SSF1 this year
I have no issue with C4, but haven't seen enough to properly comment
The broadcasters had a poor year to cover imo
I made a bit of a New Year’s resolution back in Jan to only switch over to the F1 during Q3 and the parade lap. After devoting endless hours over the years to every conceivable bit of coverage and pod-casting etc I'm very F1 weary!! Over the course of the year I've caught the odd bit of FP1/2/3 etc but on the whole I've made a deliberate ploy to not watch anything other than the important bits.
Conclusion: Best decision ever, I no longer feel obligated to watch every single snippet, my weekends suddenly became much freer and the general stress of following a particular driver evaporated and I enjoyed the sport a little more.
I think on average each year there's marginal improvement to the coverage, I think this year was a bit flat in that respect, I didn't really notice anything different or new. I welcomed C4 coming to sport, what I was saw was ok, a little too ‘teeny’ with the graphics and vibe for my liking but a solid start.
Commentators - I must declare I'm not a big fan of Ben Edwards. That said Crofty who I've usually been roughly ok with, drove me to despair this season. The suddenly dramatic rise in volume at the slightest on track action set me on edge. I got to the point where I took a compressor (rack mounted one – for you guitarists out there) and put it between my TV and audio system. I squashed the living h*ll out of the SSF1 signal and normalized Crofty’s volume. It’s not so much what he’s saying, it’s the way the volume jumps 20-30db when he goes. An extreme solution I know but it was really getting to me.
The commentator mantra is inform, educate and entertain; I didn’t really get that from the guys this year. Maybe I’m just a little too cynical but most of the times the commentators said something along the lines of ‘oh he’s in with a chance to pass here’ it was complete codswallop. It’s so obvious sometimes they’re just saying things to notch up the excitement; i found it insulting at points. I’ve watched enough to know when a driver is truly in with a chance to pass/catch etc.
I thought the commentary teams had quite poor on track action to cover, I’m not a VES fan at all but he gave them the most to work with this year. The Merc battle up front was tediously predictable and pretty much dependent each race on Lewis’s starts/reliability. You pretty much knew by T2 how the rest of the race was going. I think it was appalling for the sport that the Merc’s were crawling on Sunday and still nobody could get realistically close. With the sport in poor form I have quite some sympathy for the coverage teams and maybe I’m being unduly harsh at points.
I thought the actual camera work was good, sharper focusing and better motion smoothening from the FOM feed(s). I don’t like the wide shots (done to include the advertising) but credit to the camera operators who I felt did a solid job this year. The saturation on the feeds were good, I think there’s still a little bit of work to do covering gamma and black levels but overall I felt the color and contrast of the main feed is the best it’s ever been.
I like to hear a bit more of the ambient audio whilst the cars are circulating. The engine note trail off was quite quick, I live pretty close to an F1 circuit and the car noise is markedly different in reality. I'm not sure if that's poor mixing or deliberate.
Roll on 2017 and hopefully a fresh injection of new rules will refresh the sport a little. Failing that there’s always Sportscars