Originally Posted by Roscoe Barnes:
“Caroline and Olly were a disaster on the live shows. They were fine at the pre-recorded sections and fell apart once it went live.
Not many potential candidates. I hope they can get Dermot back, but I won't hold my breath. What about Davina McCall or Emma Willis? Both have lots of live TV presenting experience.”
Yes I'd agree with that. I quite liked them on the recorded shows (well, mainly Olly as Caroline didn't seem to turn up for half of them!) but it didn't work live.
Emma Willis is an interesting shout. Obviously she's on The Voice but Cowell isn't averse to a bit of poaching and the headlines it generates. Plus it could work well as ITV might want new hosts on The Voice anyway to make it feel like a new show.
Davina's great but I doubt she'd do it. I think after last year they probably need a relatively safe pair of hands (although Caroline Flack probably seemed reasonably safe at the time!). Stephen Mulhern is surely a no-no. Melvin & Rochelle were fine on Xtra but I wouldn't promote them to the main show. Dave Berry if they still want someone off the radio? Again a bit uninspiring.
One potential idea could be to get a comedian on there to try and make it a bit more lighthearted, but in practice I'm not sure how well that'd actually work.
Would be quite amusing if both Dermot and Louis Walsh end up back on the show this year. Would make last year's revamp look totally redundant. Maybe they should have just stuck with what they had in 2014 (or even in 2013 but with Cowell in for Barlow).