Originally Posted by
Score:
“Another singing show on top of the ones we've already got, just what we need. 
Seriously they should consider doing something different. I can't see a new talent show anchored by Gary Barlow being the next big thing. He was pretty poor on X Factor and I imagine a talent show produced by him would take itself quite seriously.”
If its Barlow approaching the BBC rather than the other way around there is probably little chance of this being taken on. It depends whether its viable as a show but also on whether the BBC are belligerent enough in the face of charter renewal or not. Having lost a show pointedly singled out as an area it shouldn't be dabbling in, replacing it with another might be seen as inflammatory just now.
That said talent shows(public or celebrity) are still the number one shiny floor format, and as things stand there shouldn't be any barriers to the BBC being part of that genre. I guess the way its done has got to be somewhat different to make it stand out-but that's easier said than done.
EDIT: I just have this vague memory that Gary Barlow has pushed a format to the BBC before which was rejected-might be wrong.