I don't get the love for him, either. I've never seen G.Shore, so maybe he's overwhelmingly entertaining on that, but in this he's just any other mediocre housemate.
I saw a bit of live feed the other day (just after Jeremy had said on bots that Scotty had a gf on the outside) and he's not interesting in normal (non highlighted) time either. All he has to offer the highlights show is his grinding with Tiffany and diary room entries where he loves on himself. Can anyone really be that confident about their looks and willy.
Even though I don't particularly like John now, I feel even he has offered more than Scotty t, entertainment wise overall. Even Steph who has gone through cheating-gate is more entertaining. Danielle who's relatively fragile (despite seeming hard) has let it all hang out. Tiff also trumps him. Scotty is down at the bottom with Darren for me in terms of being irrelevant hms. The showmance with Megan didn't work for him, and being just him isn't enough.