Originally Posted by batdude_uk1:
“The point is they didn't get him, so if they want a player from us, it will be on our terms, and if we wish to sell them, we are not a club that Real can just rush in and decide that they want a player, and then get them just like that.
I was not meaning to re-open old arguments or debates, I merely just used his name as an analogy to the situation that was being talked about.”
But he's the wrong example to use, because he didn't stay on your terms. He stayed because Real Madrid made a mistake.
The fact that they didn't get him doesn't suit your argument about them wanting Pogba because they only didn't get him because of a mistake. Had he said no from the beginning and signed the contract, then you could use him. If he didn't stay quiet about the whole thing then come minutes away from signing for them, but for an admin error, then you could use him. But he didn't stay out of loyalty, regardless of him signing a contract after the deal fell through.
He doesn't work in your example because them failing to get your player had absolutely nothing to do with you. If you sign Pogba and they come in for him in a couple years, the fact that they failed to sign De Gea because of an admin error won't protect you. It won't mean anything.