Originally Posted by Nico_D:
“I'm hopeful he will be done with them by July”
“I'm hopeful he will be done with them by July”
I hope so
Emmerdale: Aaron Livesy and Robert Sugden Appreciation Thread (Part 7)
502 of 549
Originally Posted by amy_ryan1:
“Yeah I doubt we will ever get a mention, although I think there could have been a point made of it around the times that Robert would say about Andy not been Jack's real son.. I know it's different but either Andy/Vic or Diane may have mentioned something about Roberts biological mother I guess.
I think I'm seeing it from me as a mother myself, I know if I'd have died when I gave birth to my son, then my hubby & another woman brought him up & my son never spoke of me or seen me as his real mum, that's heartbreaking.. of course this is soapland tho lol.”
“Yeah I doubt we will ever get a mention, although I think there could have been a point made of it around the times that Robert would say about Andy not been Jack's real son.. I know it's different but either Andy/Vic or Diane may have mentioned something about Roberts biological mother I guess.
I think I'm seeing it from me as a mother myself, I know if I'd have died when I gave birth to my son, then my hubby & another woman brought him up & my son never spoke of me or seen me as his real mum, that's heartbreaking.. of course this is soapland tho lol.”
Yeah, but dramatically I can see how it would be a dead end. No one in the village knows Robert's biological mother and he doesn't remember her. I think its one of those things that would be interesting in real life but not on television. Storylines should have the ability to provide on conflict or drama among existing characters.
Originally Posted by sderr123:
“Yeah, but dramatically I can see how it would be a dead end. No one in the village knows Robert's biological mother and he doesn't remember her. I think its one of those things that would be interesting in real life but not on television. Storylines should have the ability to provide on conflict or drama among existing characters.”
“Yeah, but dramatically I can see how it would be a dead end. No one in the village knows Robert's biological mother and he doesn't remember her. I think its one of those things that would be interesting in real life but not on television. Storylines should have the ability to provide on conflict or drama among existing characters.”
I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother
Originally Posted by Lmack:
“I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother”
“I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother”
I don't think he sees her as his mother though. He was lucky that Sarah treated him like her own and from what I remember he was a bit of a mummy's boy.
Originally Posted by Lmack:
“I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother”
“I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother”
I suppose it could be brought up every once and again. I just don't think it'd be as interesting as you think.
Originally Posted by Nico_D:
“I don't think he sees her as his mother though. He was lucky that Sarah treated him like her own and from what I remember he was a bit of a mummy's boy.”
“I don't think he sees her as his mother though. He was lucky that Sarah treated him like her own and from what I remember he was a bit of a mummy's boy.”
Robert's feeling about Sarah are more interesting because it loops into is relationship with Andy and Vic.
[B[/b]
Yeah I agree, Robert has lost a biological mother & a mother he grew up with & called his mum, in real life he would naturally mention the fact he never knew his birth mother.
Originally Posted by Lmack:
“I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother”
“I think it could have still been discussed though at points.It would be nice to see what he really feels about it,regardless of whether anyone knew his mother”
Yeah I agree, Robert has lost a biological mother & a mother he grew up with & called his mum, in real life he would naturally mention the fact he never knew his birth mother.
Originally Posted by amy_ryan1:
“[B[/b]
Yeah I agree, Robert has lost a biological mother & a mother he grew up with & called his mum, in real life he would naturally mention the fact he never knew his birth mother.”
“[B[/b]
Yeah I agree, Robert has lost a biological mother & a mother he grew up with & called his mum, in real life he would naturally mention the fact he never knew his birth mother.”
Robert also lost an uncle he was close to an older brother he never knew and a half sister who left when he was a baby/toddler, him and Andy should have had therapy throughout there teens, it would have solved a LOT of their problems
Originally Posted by Nico_D:
“I don't think he sees her as his mother though. He was lucky that Sarah treated him like her own and from what I remember he was a bit of a mummy's boy.”
“I don't think he sees her as his mother though. He was lucky that Sarah treated him like her own and from what I remember he was a bit of a mummy's boy.”
Yes I know but I still think it would be natural for him to speak of her in some sort of way
Originally Posted by Lmack:
“Yes I know but I still think it would be natural for him to speak of her in some sort of way”
“Yes I know but I still think it would be natural for him to speak of her in some sort of way”
I know what you mean but I think it would amount to a throw away sentence that he never knew her, I think it would be a bigger deal if he didn't have Sarah as he would have spent his childhood pining for a mother figure and probably ended up putting her on a pedestal.
Originally Posted by sderr123:
“I suppose it could be brought up every once and again. I just don't think it'd be as interesting as you think.”
“I suppose it could be brought up every once and again. I just don't think it'd be as interesting as you think.”
I don't necessarily think it would be hugely interesting to everyone, but I think it would be a nice touch to hear Robert as an adult talk about her,what could have been etc
Originally Posted by amy_ryan1:
“[B[/b]
Yeah I agree, Robert has lost a biological mother & a mother he grew up with & called his mum, in real life he would naturally mention the fact he never knew his birth mother.”
“[B[/b]
Yeah I agree, Robert has lost a biological mother & a mother he grew up with & called his mum, in real life he would naturally mention the fact he never knew his birth mother.”
Yeah he definately would
Originally Posted by Nico_D:
“Robert also lost an uncle he was close to an older brother he never knew and a half sister who left when he was a baby/toddler, him and Andy should have had therapy throughout there teens, it would have solved a LOT of their problems”
“Robert also lost an uncle he was close to an older brother he never knew and a half sister who left when he was a baby/toddler, him and Andy should have had therapy throughout there teens, it would have solved a LOT of their problems”
The half sister, Sandie, is still alive and living in Scotland. Jack, who is not her father, used to mention her.
Originally Posted by Nico_D:
“I know what you mean but I think it would amount to a throw away sentence that he never knew her, I think it would be a bigger deal if he didn't have Sarah as he would have spent his childhood pining for a mother figure and probably ended up putting her on a pedestal.”
“I know what you mean but I think it would amount to a throw away sentence that he never knew her, I think it would be a bigger deal if he didn't have Sarah as he would have spent his childhood pining for a mother figure and probably ended up putting her on a pedestal.”
It's definately good that he had Sarah
Originally Posted by abrightyz:
“danny in that suit for the bafta's
”
“danny in that suit for the bafta's
”
I know he was gorgeous.....
I loved how even though Danny begrudgingly applauded for EE Elizabeth didn't even bother....!
Originally Posted by Fhionnuisce:
“cos Jimmy is just seen as a comedy, although not sure who by though. If it was either of them it would deffo be seen as more
”
“cos Jimmy is just seen as a comedy, although not sure who by though. If it was either of them it would deffo be seen as more
”
lolz
Originally Posted by Joni_Kille:
“I know he was gorgeous.....
I loved how even though Danny begrudgingly applauded for EE Elizabeth didn't even bother....!”
“I know he was gorgeous.....
I loved how even though Danny begrudgingly applauded for EE Elizabeth didn't even bother....!
”
eeekk ha ha ha
Originally Posted by Joni_Kille:
“I know he was gorgeous.....
I loved how even though Danny begrudgingly applauded for EE Elizabeth didn't even bother....!”
“I know he was gorgeous.....
I loved how even though Danny begrudgingly applauded for EE Elizabeth didn't even bother....!
”
She did clap, she just stopped while the others carried on
Originally Posted by Alanna_Housden:
“She did clap, she just stopped while the others carried on”
“She did clap, she just stopped while the others carried on”
Clearly thinking that was all they deserved!!!
Originally Posted by Alanna_Housden:
“She did clap, she just stopped while the others carried on”
“She did clap, she just stopped while the others carried on”
was nodding when i watched (from busy night shift
)... will watch again lolz
502 of 549
