Remember over the last few years people wanted rid of him had it, stuck in the past cliched comments etc all perfectly true.

However now people especially on here want him back on the whole, so why the about turn

because people have limited imaginations and seem to think the show will be better served by someone who hasn't had an original thought since the 90s

no idea id rather have Grimmy

I've always loved Walsh but I do think people have seen after last year how vital he is to the show - he brings a lot of heart, fun and silliness.

They want him back because they didn't like his replacement last year. I would rather they have someone else replace Grimmy instead of bringing back Louis tbh, i would only tolerate his return if it was a reunion of previous judges e.g. Simon, Cheryl, Dannii/Sharon, Louis.

He brings comedy to the show. It was boring last year