amanda's golden buzzer act (spoiler)

3 of 3

Verrillion

13-04-2016

Ive got a problem with kiddies on the show in that they seem to be praised to high heaven way above any abilitys. Is it not perverse to have kids perform for a group of leering middle aged judges when they have little skill or abilitys beyond youth.
The time for gushing over Shirley Temples doing modern versions of The Good Ship Lollipop should be consigned to history with the likes of Jimmy Saville.

Grumpy_Alan

15-04-2016

Originally Posted by Verrillion:
“Ive got a problem with kiddies on the show in that they seem to be praised to high heaven way above any abilitys. Is it not perverse to have kids perform for a group of leering middle aged judges when they have little skill or abilitys beyond youth.
The time for gushing over Shirley Temples doing modern versions of The Good Ship Lollipop should be consigned to history with the likes of Jimmy Saville.”

^^^ This

CBFreak

15-04-2016

Originally Posted by Nigel_Bourne:
“Why is somebody going to stage school such a bad thing? How else are they supposed to learn to hone what this girl clearly has in bucketloads - natural talent?

I thought she sang in a very clean pitch, good timbre with a passable interpretation of a tricky song, both pitch and dynamic wise. She was assured, confident and has a lovely voice. And she wasn't trying to "do" someone else, as most female vocalists seem to attempt, A la Beyonce, or Whitney...she sang in her own voice. I really enjoyed listening to her. She'd have blown them away on "The Voice"”

I meant how she sang it. It wasn't from the gut more something she learned through repetitive behaviour including some bad stage school habits like gurning through a song. I prefer a more natural singer

SULLA

16-04-2016

Originally Posted by valkay:
“Apparently Simon has warned David not to use his golden buzzer for any rubbish acts, like he did last year.”

But the golden buzzer is a waste of time if the act would get 4 yeses anyway.

It should surely be used when the 'judge' really likes them and doesn't think they will get the 3 yeses.

JohnStannard

23-04-2016

Amanda pressed the gold button for a act that deserved it, seems could be from a talented family and has the potential to last a while on the show

lewismacf

23-04-2016

David preses his golden buzzer this week

3 of 3