Originally Posted by davidnumen:
“American shows don't have the cachet they used to have on UK television - nothing matches the likes of Dallas, Dynasty, The Incredible Hulk, The Six Million Dollar Man - these shows came when we had only 3 mainstream channels and dominated ratings pretty well from memory. These days such shows are left to the minority channels such as Channel 5 and Sky. They simply don't have a huge ratings presence and IF ratings is a priority (and given how they've dipped in recent years I think the Xmas episode is a good one to use to boost ratings) then it's much more newsworthy to have, say, Benedict Cumberbatch (unlikely but you get my point - someone from an actual high profile mainstream show) than John Barrowman. I think he's too divisive among fans to even make an impact with the diehards - not that they matter as far as ratings are concerned anyway. I don't mind Captain Jack - I don't have a particular fondness for him but given a good story he'd be welcome however I don't think his return would in any way be a ratings booster. I might be wrong, but certainly as far as UK audiences are concerned I think there's likely a huge crossover with the Who viewership anyway.”
Game of thrones(gets better UK ratings than most UK shows),The walking dead, American Horror story, and yes, though you refuse to believe it - the dc universe tv shows - all examples of American shows being popular in the UK.
Maisie Williams appearance in who last year was all over the media both when she was announced and then again when her episodes were due to air
directly Because of her popularity in the UK from being in an american show
The very fact that there are more channels than ever now, and American shows still do well, despite so much choice, suggests that they are more popular than ever.
Besides, as I've consistently stated, it's not just about his presence in those DC shows alone.
From Torchwood still thriving in the form of audio's and books, to yes, his presence in those DC tv shows, to say, the popularity he might have from his various UK presenting jobs he has had, there is much evidence to suggest he is a popular actor, and the character is still popular.
Like I said earlier, if you don't particularly think much of the character and don't want to see him back, then thats fine and you should just say that, but there's no point in trying to project that onto the wider audience by suggesting he's not popular in general, when there is much evidence to suggest that he is both as an actor and as the character.