Originally Posted by
SecretLifeoBees:
“If the Neighbours Facebook page is anything to go by there are hell of a lot of people both religious and non-religious offended by this storyline. The most common points raised seem to be
1. The disrespect being shown to the church and people of faith by implying their beliefs are easily swayed.
2. The disrespect being shown towards Jack by Paige.
3. Paige's constant displays of desperation.
I hope they have him remain in the church. Has Neighbours had a regular character as a man of the cloth at all? Plus it would show Paige she can't always get what she wants.
Knowing Paige she will probably make a play for Father Vincent instead
”
I can understand people being offended by this storyline. On the one hand it's meant to be entertainment, but not at the expense of making light of someone's religious beliefs. As a person who was raised Christian, I can't say I'm offended as such, there's always some kind of dramatic licence given with most storylines, but the casual attitudes of some of the characters just isn't sitting right with me just the same.
Paige is like a kid with a shiny new toy, 'I want it and I'm going to stamp my feet until I get it' attitude. Does she think Jack's religious beliefs are mysteriously going to vanish once she gets her man? The bigger picture if Jack did chose to leave the priesthood, and if the writers stuck to any kind of believability, would be that Jack continued to be involved in the church and kept his beliefs but knowing soaps, the writers would probably downplay that side of him until it was needed for some kind of plot device. It's so wrong to portray religion as something that can be picked up and dropped at will. And I can hardly see Paige as the go-to-church-on-Sunday type of person, I don't think she's religious at all. Not that she has to be, but she's shown no interest in getting to know that side of Jack apart from telling her mum she was going to read a few pages of the Bible to try to get to know Jack better.
I thought Father Vincent was rather rude to Paige even if she did need telling off. He probably did get the wrong impression of her from what Jack was telling him but he doesn't know Paige and I didn't like that he judged her so quickly.
Originally Posted by kitkat1971:
“The thing that keeps striking me which i hate is the way people (not just Paige but others including Aaron) keep saying that he's not with the Church 'at the moment'. As though it is some kind of 'free pass' 'what happens in Erinsborough, stays in Erinsborough', 'stag weekend' deal where if he does regret sleeping with Paige, or the relationship doesn't work, no harm will be done and he can just skip back to being a Priest with a clear conscience. Hmmm no, he would still have broken his vows and he wouldn't be able to forget that, even if the church were willing to turn a blind eye. Or do they assume he would just keep quiet about it?
.”
This exactly! Brad and Lauren should be telling Paige loud and clear to back off but they're not. Aaron's acting like it's just some normal boyfriend/girlfriend relationship 'wink wink nudge nudge' get her into bed and everything will be fine. None of them seem to have a clue, and I didn't blame Jack for being upset by Aaron's inappropriate comments.
Originally Posted by mrs.deschanel:
“I think Piper is being written badly too. She wasn't this bratty child who needed her own way all of the time before nor did she constantly go off in a strop with her bum stuck out. She was a bit edgy (if you consider wearing 90s clothes edgy) and has now gone to full on spoilt little tart trying to get Tyler into bed. Paige has always been a spoiled princess but she's gone way too far with this Jack thing. The priesthood is a vocation - it's Jack's whole life. It's not something he can walk away from lightly because he's seen Paige's norks or she's wearing a tarty frock (which looked like a cross between a parachute and a tent). She seems to be taking it on as a challenge because she wants him so has to have him. She was never this bad before and even showed some vulnerability and empathy with the Michelle/Tomato storyline. The writers are poor at the moment with all younger females. Steph is still strong, Sonya still ditzy, Susan still a busybody who cares for others, Amy still tough but a weird mother to evil Jimmy etc. so why ruin Paige, Piper and Xanthe? Xanthe was showing more than dim celeb obsessed irritant - where's that gone? What happened to her learning difficulties? She needs more depth.”
Well tbf he didn't actually see Paige's norks did he?
I liked Piper when she first came to RS, as you say she was edgy and seemed like she was going to be pretty cool young character but this storyline with Tyler has turned her into a selfish little brat who will do anything including lying to her parents and sneak around behind their backs just because they disapprove of the boy she's desperate to be with. Xanthe's behaviour hasn't been much better, the whole money theft storyline was written as though she and the others should be let off with just a slap on the writst.