Originally Posted by Andy_JS:
“One of my least favourite number ones of the 80s. Sorry Shaky. Would have preferred either Kraftwerk or the Stranglers to be number one this week.”
Shaky was definitely on the slide, i'd say, despite ''Oh Julie'' making No 1. All of his previous singles were better, despite ''It's Raining'', his last single, only reaching No 10. I tend to put that down more to the change of pace to Shaky's more uptempo numbers, than ''It's Raining'' being a more mediocre track. ''Oh Julie'' though seemed very slight by comparison, and was a taster for the type of going-through-the-motions type singles he would release from now on. Its No 1 placing does seem to give the song a misleadingly high profile, as if it may rank alongside his best, which i think is not deserved. I would imagine Shaky would have got a kick out of it reaching No 1, though, especially as he wrote it himself.
Songs like ''Oh Julie'', alongside Elkie Brooks ''Fool If You Think It's Over'' and Alton Edwards ''I Just Wanna'', aren't perhaps the most inspiring of tracks, but they also aren't truly bad. In the context of those previous appearances, they did shine brighter, because those shows as a whole had more highpoints, and they were carried along by the flow somewhat. In the context of this episode, where there was plenty of true mediocrity, i don't think these songs were quite strong enough to drag the show out of its slump. Perhaps only the great Stranglers track ''Golden Brown'' from the whole of the show managed that, and that was only momentary.
It seems unbelievable to think Tight Fit's ''The Lion Sleeps Tonight'' actually managed to reach No 1, and stay there for three weeks, when the charts were still fairly inspiring, on the whole. It seems like an early example of the charts becoming dominated by disposable pop, as they have been in the last decade or two. Haircut 100's ''Love Plus One'' is ok, and certainly not mediocre, but i prefer the more funky previous single, ''Favourite Shirts'', from them. Stiff Little Fingers ''Listen'', from the EP of the same name, struck me as being the weakest song they had promoted, in their Top Of The Pops appearances, up to that point. I think their more pure punk sound suited them better, although, of course, times do change, and they wouldn't want to be seen as standing still. Olivia Newton John's ''Landslide'' wasn't a great choice for a single. It wasn't anywhere near as irritating as ''Physical'', mind, but also nowhere near as catchy. Olivia had really come to the end of her days as a successful singles artist around this point, and her very contemporary 80s style video, couldn't disguise the song's lack of hit potential.
The one big positive to this episode was that Simon Bates wasn't anywhere near as irritating as he has been at times.
5.5/10