Originally Posted by starry:
“That's similar to me. I won't like most hip hop, that's for those who have bought into the whole culture of it. And that's how it is looked at often I think, not simply just music. But I can appreciate things here and there anyway as I made an effort to listen to older stuff and modern stuff and work out what I think is more creative or fresher (and separating what I think is just hyped).
Key things for me are a powerful voice (attitude), interesting rhythms, sometimes an interesting production and some catchiness. Sometimes that can be encouraged by good lyrics. It leads on from r&b music, and I think it can be looked at from that simple rhythmic energy, but also combined with an underground attitude which may be meant to shock those not ready for it. There are also more 'pop' songs around the world which incorporate a hip-hop element into them to add some attitude and energy, some can be quite successful from my experience. As with anything I just think it depends on how well it's done and not the style used per se.
But for me that's from listening to music and not reading about it or watching something on it. Nothing beats listening to as much as possible. Words are pretty much pointless I think it's about adjusting the brain to have a better understanding of different styles. If I feel I can understand and appreciate some things of a style then I definitely think that's progress. Also I think the top 40, or even just a Western perspective, are limitations that may not always help”
“That's similar to me. I won't like most hip hop, that's for those who have bought into the whole culture of it. And that's how it is looked at often I think, not simply just music. But I can appreciate things here and there anyway as I made an effort to listen to older stuff and modern stuff and work out what I think is more creative or fresher (and separating what I think is just hyped).
Key things for me are a powerful voice (attitude), interesting rhythms, sometimes an interesting production and some catchiness. Sometimes that can be encouraged by good lyrics. It leads on from r&b music, and I think it can be looked at from that simple rhythmic energy, but also combined with an underground attitude which may be meant to shock those not ready for it. There are also more 'pop' songs around the world which incorporate a hip-hop element into them to add some attitude and energy, some can be quite successful from my experience. As with anything I just think it depends on how well it's done and not the style used per se.
But for me that's from listening to music and not reading about it or watching something on it. Nothing beats listening to as much as possible. Words are pretty much pointless I think it's about adjusting the brain to have a better understanding of different styles. If I feel I can understand and appreciate some things of a style then I definitely think that's progress. Also I think the top 40, or even just a Western perspective, are limitations that may not always help”
I know what you mean. At my age (52) I should have settled down to tuning my FM radio right to the bottom of the dial and locked myself into Radio 2. I have not, partly because a lot of Radio 2 is not for me (daytime mainly). Also, there is now that internet obviously, and the fact that I can listen to any number of radio stations on TuneIn. Dandelion Radio is great although I need to be in the mood for it, but there are also a few American, Canadian and European Jazz stations on it, which frankly blow the UK Jazz FM out of the water.
At the moment, I am transferring a lot of my old cassettes on to my MP3 player and am currently at the early 1990s. I am amazed that I listened to so much Atlantic 252 at the time (with its poor reception), but in all honestly, although I did not dislike BBC radio 1, the problem for me with Radio 1 is the endless chat between the records (which they still do these days). A252 kept chat to a minimum and also broke a few records onto the scene which were later picked up by other stations.
Listening today to my nineties phase on my cassettes is proof positive in my opinion, that 90s music was nowhere near as bad as some other posters are convinced that it was.
After about 2007 is around that time that I stopped listening out for chart music, as to be fair to everyone, top 40 music nowadays is not written for me. Spotify and Youtube are my saviours these days. If someone suggests a band which I may like, all I need to is check them out at those sites, and I can either become a fan, or not bother.
And in my case I am more of a melody person rather than lyrics, although one reason why I love the Divine Comedy are his great lyrics as well as his choons.
Ref your last point, one of the limitations on top 40 music is precisely that - there are only 40 songs available. Using my clever little laptop, I have access to thousands of songs whenever I like.





”


- By the way - I think every new band should name their first single after their band name to help newcomers remember who/what the band/song is!
(Sorry Mark if you ever read this!!)”