Originally Posted by Andy_JS:
“One reason it wasn't a great show was that there weren't that many new performances in the studio. Culture Club, Bauhaus and Spandau Ballet were repeats from earlier shows. I think the new ones were Piranhas, Toyah and Sharon Redd. Not quite as bad as the Savile show from October 1981 where it was all videos apart from This Year's Blonde IIRC.”
I'm not sure about the repeat performances having any bearing on this episode being mediocre. It just lacked truly memorable songs, in my opinion. Toyah's ''Be Loud Be Proud (Be Heard)'' and Imagination's ''In The Heat Of The Night'', just seemed to drag, and i was just longing for them to be over so we could get onto the next song. In a sense, Toyah and Imagination's diminishing chart fortunes was due to the later material just not quite matching their earlier songs. I certainly believe by late 82, the audience was still willing to lap them up, it is just that what they were offering fell a little short. They both sounded a little like a spent force.
Spandau Ballet's ''Lifeline'' showed them perhaps concentrating more on the strength of the material, than their songs off the 'Diamond' album, but with Swain and Jolley producing, their sound was becoming much more slick. I find them becoming a little bland sounding around this period, but certainly more accessible to a wider audience. I am not the biggest fan of ''Lifeline'', mind, and i find the backing vocals on this track, and their follow up, ''Communication'', both irritating, and rather wimpy. They would have been better leaving the whoo whoo-ing off.
I was never a fan of the Piranhas ''Zambezi'', either, and i think their cover of ''Tom Hark'' was much more enjoyable. The girl vocalists from Paul Young's future backing band do seem to be in evidence on this Piranhas Top Of The Pops clip, too.
The Kids From Fame's ''Starmaker'' did seem a little too sickly, although there is a very moving background story to the song, concerning the actor who was central to the video, only having months to live in reality. The song, though, traded on the story, and also the theme of the particular episode really well, but that perhaps seems the only reason it was such a major hit, because for me, it also does appear rather vomit inducing.
I don't believe Shakin' Stevens ''I'll Be Satisfied'' to be quite as bad as some on here think. Shaky did release a number of singles in this period (''Shirley'' and ''Give Me Your Heart Tonight'' included) which i think work on their own terms reasonably well, but they just don't seem quite as memorable as his 1980/81 releases. They lack the edge, or some of the bite, so to speak of his most successful singles, but i do feel at least Shaky wasn't recording straight copies in the style of what had already proved successful. There was a bit of a French vibe on ''Give Me Your Heart Tonight'' and ''I'll Be Satisfied'' does feature some thundering drum sounds.
Sharon Redd's ''Never Give You Up'' may just have been one of the highlights, of the show, because there were a few interesting elements to this song. It certainly has a very contemporary 1982 sound, but i'm not sure how it rates with the best dance tracks from 82. I haven't made my mind up on that score!. It is very catchy, mind, and as i have previously mentioned, in the context of this episode, it may be one of the better moments. I certainly prefer it to Kool And The Gang's ''Ooh La La La (Let’s Go Dancin'’), which for me, was one of their less impressive single releases.
Bauhaus would have been better to have left ''Ziggy Stardust'' well alone, because they add little to it. However, it did manage to at least raise their profile for a while.
4.5/10