Originally Posted by patsylimerick:
“Completely agree. She was one of my favourites on night one and - kudos, Veri - you were the only poster I remember who didn't join the Georgina love-in from the first night.
As the days went on, however, I saw that Georgina is what she is, an entitled, controlling, unpleasant little brat.”
Having her as one of your favourites on launch night seems fine to me, but many people seemed to like her more strongly than that.
I didn't join the love-in because it was too soon for viewers to have good reasons to like her so much, and because of her Day 1 highlights DR bitching about Evelyn, which seemed tactical -- an attempt to influence viewer's perceptions. (Also, Goergina's popularity came with so strong a reaction to her looks that it had to be a major factor in many cases.)
I thought there should have been at least a question mark over her, a wait and see.
A curious thing happens at the start of a new series. If someone makes negative comments about a HM, they're told it's too soon to judge; but it's rare for anyone making positive comments to be told that. There was even one poster (I'm sorry, but I've forgotten their name) who even
argued that positive comments were reasonable, even though negative comments weren't.
But such judgements, positive or negative, have to be based on relatively superficial things, although they can be evaluated with the help of our experience with other HMs and our knowledge of the sorts of people who try to get into BB and who BB tends to pick.
So there's Georgina. She's already been in a reality show. She seems to have media ambitions. She's using her looks. She doesn't have an ordinary job (or, it seems, any job at present). And on Day 1 she's already making negative comments about another woman (Evelyn) behind her back. (In the old days, that alone would have been a strong negative and has been treated as a strong point against some HMs even years after they were in BB).
None of that means I'll necessarily dislike having her as a HM; but I feel I've learned over the years to be suspicious of strong early popularity when there doesn't seem to be any good reason for it, and especially when how a woman looks seems to be a factor. (That's not only about being good looking. I also didn't join the early popularity of Carole and Laura in bb8, Kat in bb9, Becky in bb13, or Jale in bb15.)