Originally Posted by jda135:
“BIB 1 - completely agree. Although, I imagine entertainment producers who have been pitching to C4 over the last couple of years will be pretty pissed. Jay Hunt, who at the TV festival recently said that she was looking for distinctly C4 entertainment shows, has revived a 90s classic & bought the most successful show on TV. Not quite 'distinctly C4'.
BIB 2 - it's definitely not the C4 way. In fact, it goes against everything they promote themselves to be. 'Born Risky' is their promotional line. Poaching a show doing 10m from Britain's biggest TV channel is not risky in any way.
BIB 3 - nothing brave about it. Even if Bake Off halves its overnight audience, C4 will be looking at its most successful show. That's pretty sad & desperate for Britain's 2nd biggest commercial channel that they can't regularly reach 5m with a home-grown show.
BIB 4 - poaching one show doesn't make it "a big big player in entertainment". Remember, they "merged" (effectively shut) their entertainment department with fact ent last year. That's their general opinion of entertainment. Wonder what changed??”
Fair points, all of them.
Born Risky was always going to come back to haunt them. It already has many times. I had so many issues with that campaign anyway- so pretentious and annoying.
Hunt has done the best thing for the channel in my view, even if it proves unpopular in some quarters. They've been widely praised for their recent progress in a lot of areas but ratings wise they still lack that big noisy show. Gogglebox is a unique kind of hit for them but beyond that they are a bit lacking. Bake Off takes them to the next level and catapults them into the big league. ITV should be very worried because we saw during the Big Brother years what one big noisy show can do for a channel like C4, and although Bake Off is only a once a week thing there's the spinoffs and potentially other similar shows like the Pottery Throwdown as well to factor in, so the potential is absolutely massive if done right.
It's brave in as much as they are spending a lot of money and they have to handle it carefully given the love for the programme and try to minimise any backlash around things like adverts to avoid damaging C4's reputation and on top of that the risk of hurting their relationship with other indies. So there's a lot of risks there. But letting it go elsewhere would have hurt C4, especially as it would not have been as good a fit for ITV/C5/Sky so hard for them to watch from the sidelines and whilst championing new ideas is all well and good, it's a very slow process at times. They are better placed to find those 5m homegrown hits with Bake Off around than they are at the moment.