Originally Posted by Fudd:
“Why would Channel 4 return The Great British Bake Off to the BBC? Because a bunch of talking heads told them to?
The whole televisual world does not and should not revolve around the BBC. They're quick enough to dump shows which do not perform as well as using conditions set to pull out of contracts early - as it's their right to do.
Now I can understand the argument that Bake Off won't work on Channel 4 for a myriad of reasons. But at the end of the day it's a product, produced for money by Love. If they can claim more cash from somewhere else then why not? That's the way the commercial world works. On the flip side, the BBC has outbid it's commercial counterparts on certain contracts - for example, Match of the Day is unfeasible for commercial networks at it's current cost, as was the Six Nations before the BBC and ITV came to an agreement. Again quite rightly so, if they can afford to do so and there's public benefit in this approach. But it's swings and roundabouts, really.”
The days of returning a programme like Thames did with Dallas are long gone.
When a broadcaster commits to a show from an indie they do expect costs to rise if it's a hit, but not so much that they get priced out. That messes up relationships with broadcasters. Imagine Kudos taking Broadchurch to a rival broadcaster after one series on ITV.
The BBC is on the back foot here when they work with an indie for several years then a rival broadcaster buys it, as we saw with Talpa and The Voice. What Love Productions has done is unprecedented and hasn't exactly been applauded by some in the TV industry.