Originally Posted by mossy2103:
“But they cannot judge a bake - just like Alesha D could not judge a dance (and boy did it show).”
“But they cannot judge a bake - just like Alesha D could not judge a dance (and boy did it show).”
In which case nobody on BGT can judge many of the acts on BGT. Sharon, Louis and and Simon can't sing.
The winner knows how to bake and knows what tastes nice. I'm not sure what makes a good critic. Was Jonathan Ross capable of critiquing films? Nina Myskow used to judge acts. Piers Morgan? Hasselhoff?
The irony is people didn't like Gary Barlow but he's eminently qualified.




) around X Factor? They and we know any clash will affect X Factor more.