Originally Posted by The Difference:
“Not sure if I'm one of the people you feel is speaking "utter drivel", but as I'm one of the people who've expressed my reservations about the choice of Jim White to succeed Colin Murray, I'll flesh out why I'm far from thrilled by his appointment.
Going by his Sky Sports News work and media persona, I just don't rate the guy and don't see his appeal at all. He seems to have become the chief hype man for Sky Sports and the Premier League, I find the overblown transfer deadline day nonsense he revels in to be ridiculous and the sycophantic way in which he has dealt with Rangers' liquidation and people involved like Charles Green is also a big turn-off for me. I had hoped one of Colin's "friends", someone like Martin Kelner or Des Kelly, would move up to step into his shoes with the basic format being retained, or failing that The Two Mikes returning to mid-mornings would have suited me too. But for me, the unlikeable White is a disappointing and an unappealing choice of mid-morning hosts, who I have no real desire to listening to - and I'm not exactly looking forward to the prospects of hearing his shouty promos during commercial breaks in the many shows I do actually enjoy.
I'm not saying his show in terms of its format and content will be bad - I'm willing to give that aspect of his show a chance, as personally I didn't rate Colin Murray from his TV work, yet I found things like hosting the FA Cup final qualifying round draw every year and shining a light on other less media exposed sporting events to be really worthwhile things to broadcast - but as a personality he's someone I've long found to be a turn-off. And this is coming from me, someone you have accused in the past as being, if anything, too overly positive about talkSPORT - I think most acknowledge that I'm at least constructive when talking about the station (thanks to nedski and Billy for their kind words). Yet a number of the decisions talkSPORT have made in recent months since the Sky takeover became public knowledge, not just this move but things like cancelling Up The League and Full Contact and the increasing amount of pre-recorded filler going out in off-peak timeslots, have not been to my personal taste. That being said, I have praised the recent adjustments they've made to their live football coverage (making Jim Proudfoot their Sunday commentator, reshuffling the phone-ins in Stan Collymore's wake etc) so I have balanced those criticisms with praise where I feel it is deserved. But since July, potentially negative changes to talkSPORT's output have outweighed the positive ones in my opinion.”
No I like to think you are comprehensive and thought out with your praise (usually tons of praise on folk people hate

) or criticism!
I think if White is like deadline day, it could be a poor listen, but if it is a relaxed, maybe less hyperbolic presenting style and decent conversation (unlike Durham's poll tonight on Should Arsenal give MU their UCL spot - what...) then it could work! I'm just waiting and seeing rather than some here who just say it's going to be bad before hearing a show or 3!
As I say you are rational on this board too.