Brutally exhausting and one of the most intense episodes on TWD I think. Its set a new darker tone to an already dark show and really takes the show in a different direction now.
Although shockingly brutal and explicit, I still found it intense and Rick's performance during the episode, particularly the Carl/Axe scene is worthy of an Emmy I believe.
However, just a couple of gripes....... JDM is just not quite right for me. He plays a good villain role but is slightly camp in a slight way with how he plays it. I was expecting a brutal man and what I got was someone that felt a bit like a Panto villain in a brutal scene and it didnt fit right. The character is good and the scenes were good but I just wish he was a little less "grinning" like he was. He almost made me feel like Tim Curry (Rocky Horror) could have done the role in drag and it would have given the same effect.
I am not sure who would have played it better, but I just feel that for a brutal episode like that, he came across as a little bit too light hearted and "fun" in a way, and it it conflicted the scenes we were seeing.
He didnt detract from the intensity of the scene itself, that was still breathtaking, but he was also someone that didn't make you want to hate with a passion by looking at him. What he did yes, but how he acted, not so much.
My other gripe is that the Zombies scene in the mist felt a bit "this seems a bit pointless and needs editing down a bit" and felt we needed to get back to the action going on with the characters, and then it hit me that there is a strong danger of the show losing what people wanted, a zombie show. Suddenly we are back to Season 2-3 again where the Zombies are no more than background scenes and are nothing more annoying to the survivors than a heavy rainstorm! I tuned in to this show for the Zombie apocalypse and yet here I was wanting Rick to find the Axe so he could get back on with the Negan scenes rather than kick Zombie ass! And if that is the direction the writer is taking with this season, can most fans hold out for a proper Zombie threat again. Otherwise, as brilliant as the episode was, it was little more than a Gangster film really.
I just hope going forward that the Zombies play a big role again and that survival against them comes to the front. If it were me, I would get Rick and the gang having to go into bigger towns and cities to search for supplies to share with Negan, against overwhelming numbers of Walkers, and make it feel a lot like Season 1 again, but with the reason being that if they don't do it, Negan is going to be angry. Suddenly we have this opportunity for writers to want to go and push Rick and the group into scary zombie-related encounters and go scavenging again back to its roots, while also building up the story about how they will eventually end Negan and the Survivors.