Originally Posted by Steve Williams:
“Very droll. Of course, it's almost exactly a decade since Gabby went to the Beeb, I remember it being announced in the papers in October 2006, I think her last appearance on ITV was in December and then she made her debut on the Beeb in January 2007. I think she works really well on the Beeb too, I didn't always like her that much on ITV but I think she's really good now.
Also around that period they were easing Terry Venables back in after he left to make a hash of managing Leeds, and there was a period where he would pop up in a BT-style box during a match with "COACHES' VIEW" on top of it.”
Goodness time flies. I remember being a fan of Gabby back in her ITV days - thought she was watchable and thought it was a bit of a shame she was sidelined for Steve Ryder. Ryder was/is of course regarded as a very capable host but just felt a shame to see a woman given the role of lead football host on one of the main channels and than sidelined.
Moving to the BBC has worked out well for Gabby - though I find these days I feel I enjoy more on some programmes and coverage more than others.
I think she's very accomplished when presenting things like live football or rugby and actually I really enjoy her when she stands in for Gary on MOTD (she works well with the pundits and is more than capable for the role - it's a shame there are often the usual comments by Twitter neanderthals when she appears).
However, I'm not as impressed when she does stuff like the Athletics or light entertainment.
Originally Posted by Steve Williams:
“Of course, broadcasting outside the stadium was another of those ideas that are happily used in other sport, BT, and before that ESPN, regularly do that in their rugby coverage and it seems to work well enough. But like with the analysis on the cricket coverage, it seemingly can't just be ported across to football because the sports are very different..”
That said it really didn't take a genius to work out that it might not work in football. Rugby crowds are often different to football and most could've told them that. For BT to have thought otherwise would've been worryingly naive.
There's the old thing too that the camera is a great magnet for idiots and so broadcasting outside means you're bound to attract one or two.
It always seemed a bit pointless to me too. I still don't understand what they thought they gained from it compared to say broadcasting in a studio. In fact, it's arguable the pundits would end up having to miss part of the game they're actually meant to be watching to get there in time.