Originally Posted by Welsh-lad:
“Ah right. It's how my dad house-trained our dog many years ago.
Seemed to work very well...”
I'm surprised it worked at all to be honest. There is so little education value in such a method.
Think through the dogs eyes, what is that teaching them?
Is it teaching them they should go outside? Not really.
Is it teaching them never to toilet in the house, or is it teaching them not to toilet in that spot in that room? (so the dog finds other inside places to go).
Is it simply teaching them not to do their business when mummy or daddy is watching? (so the dog learns simply to do it when not being watched, or sneak off to a bedroom or behind the sofa etc). Then you've created what's called an owner absent problem, it's taught the dog to save it up until they know you're not watching or have popped out, and now you're powerless to correct the behaviour because you can't catch it in the act any more.
The very best way I know of for toilet training is as follows :
1] Spend plenty of time outdoors with them, especially after a meal which is likely to stimulate the need to pee or poop within 30 mins max at a guess. Close the door so no-ones going back indoors until there's been some emptying outdoors. When they do their business outside, lots of verbal praise and offer a tasty treat. Not just once, but three times "good dog" treat "good dog" treat "good dog" treat. Really lay it on!
2] Put going to the toilet on cue. Remember girl and boy dogs can pee on demand to mark territory and leave their calling cards behind, so unlike us humans they can squeeze a wee out pretty much whenever. I use "go toilet" but some folk prefer something more subtle like "get busy". Just start saying your chosen word whilst he's doing his business outside (and of course praise and treat afterward). Now you can COMMUNICATE with him. Guide to the dog to where you want them to go, and simply ask him to "go toilet". "ahh so that's where you want me to go!". Now you can also have the dog empty their tanks before a trip to the vets or a car journey etc!
3] Teach the meaning of Inside and Outside verbal cues. So so easy, just stand in the doorway to the garden, say "Outside" and toss a treat a few feet across the threshold and repeat a dozen times. Then do a test and just say the words and see what happens. Then the same for Inside (which is darn useful to call your dog back in from the garden without wearing out his recall etc). Once it's clear those are understood, next time there is an accident indoors you can communicate "No! Outside! Outside! Outside!".
You can't teach anything after it's happened. You've got maybe 2 seconds at the very best for a dog to associate cause and effect. Indoor accidents that you didn't see are too late to do anything about so have to be ignored, it's not the dogs fault, they just weren't being supervised well enough. Watch them like a hawk and restrict their movements and access around the house whilst working on the problem.