Originally Posted by Francy:
“I hope that's not James' secret. It would be so boring... the "your father is not your real father" reveal has been done so many times. Besides, I'd prefer James to be Mac's son and therefore fully part of the Nightingale clan (with whom I hope he well get to interact more in the future), not being Mac's son would separate him even more from the rest of the family.”
I agree. Apart from me not thinking or wanting this to be the big secret, I don't like the idea of Mac not being James's father. I like the thought of their relationship being strained because of issues they have as father and son. I think that angle is far more interesting than the 'I don't care for you much because you are not mine' predictability. The only way I'd be okayish with this plot is is Mac was in the dark about this. I'd like to think that despite their delicate relationship that Mac still see's James as his son and loves him all the same.
Originally Posted by margarite6666:
“I can't think of any other reason for the comment about Mac playing football with Nathan and Marnie and James being left out. James did say he looked after his siblings so they do care for each other.”
I think it's purely because Nathan is quite similar to his dad in alot of ways and that Nathan is what you call a lads lad. He is into footy and he wears his heart on his sleeve. James on the other hand, is what I can imagine wasn't a 'typical son' and because of that, Mac had difficulty bonding with him. I don't think it helped with Marnie dripping poison in his ear either.
Originally Posted by LilMissBossy:
“I think James's secret has something to do with Japan and those Japanese cups / vases that JP picked up and was so firmly told to put down.”
Yes, yes, THIS! It's the exact thought I had when the scene first aired.
They belonged to someone James cared about in his past. Something bad happened to the person, maybe by Jame's hand.
I'm calling it now!